Yeah... you know questions like these would have long answers.
If it has parentheses after it, it most likely means I got it for free from my friend or it's special.
Here's all 98 Ponies!
Merch
Fluttershy Yay Shirt
My Little Pony Forever Grey Hoodie
Derpy I Just Don't Know What Went Wrong Shirt
Rainbow Dash Paint Shirt
Doctor Whooves Trust Me I'm A Doctor Shirt
My Little Pony Characters Lanyard
My Little Pony "Ponies Forever" Shot Glass (from my pony friend)
Enterplay Trading Card Tin
Enterplay Trading Card Pinkie Pie Box
My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Mini Bubble Baths
"It's About To Get Magical" Shirt (from my pony friend)
20+ Enterplay Trading Cards
Ponies
McDonalds Ponies
2005
Sparkleworks (from my pony friend)
2008 (Order of Obtained)
1 Rainbow Dash (from my pony friend)
2 Cheerilee
3 Pinkie Pie
4 Starsong (MLPTP from Unicorngirl!)
5 Sweetie Belle (MLPTP from Unicorngirl!)
6 Scootaloo (from my pony friend)
2009 (Order of Obtained)
1 Cheerilee (from my pony friend)
2 Scootaloo (from my pony friend)
3 Pinkie Pie (from my pony friend)
4 Starsong (from my pony friend)
5 Pinkie Pie
6 Scootaloo
7 Scootaloo
8 Sweetie Belle
2011 (Order of Obtained)
1 Rainbow Dash (Free)
2 Twilight Sparkle (Free)
3 Fluttershy (from my pony friend)
4 Applejack
5 Rarity
6 Fluttershy
7 Princess Cadance (MLPTP from Unicorngirl!)
Ponyville
Sunnydaze
Sparkleworks
Minty
Minty Christmas
Pinkie Pie
Wysteria
Plushies
Funrise 5" Rainbow Dash
Funrise 5" Pinkie Pie
Funrise 5" Twilight Sparkle
Funrise 10" Rainbow Dash
Funrise 10" Pinkie Pie
Funrise 11" Twilight Sparkle
Generation 1 (from my pony friend)
Fizzy
Cherry Treats
Princess Misty
Sherbet
Glory
Skydancer
Cherries Jubilee
Generation 3
Pretty Pattern Pony Fancy Free
Pretty Pattern Pony Summer Bloom
Pinkie Pie (from my pony friend)
Generation 3.5
Styling Large Pinkie Pie (from my pony friend, also my FAVORITE pony of the year)
Sweetie Belle Sparkly Pony & Activity Book
Generation 4
Blind Bags:
Wave 4 (Order of Obtained)
1 Royal Riff (My FIRST pony of 2012)
2 Crimson Gala
3 Minuette
4 Electric Sky
5 Shoeshine
6 Twilight Sparkle
7 Metallic Applejack
8 Metallic Rarity
9 Rainbow Dash
10 Lulamoon (from my pony friend)
11 Amethyst Star (from my pony friend)
12 Twilight Velvet (from my pony friend)
13 Rarity
14 Metallic Pinkie Pie
15 Pinkie Pie
16 Fluttershy
17 Applejack
18 Molsey Orange
19 Sassaflash
20 Mosley Orange
21 Mosley Orange
22 Merry May
Pony Collection Set
Beachberry
Skywishes
Gardenia Glow
Sweetsong
Coconut Cream
Rainbow Dash
Twilight Sparkle
Rarity
Pinkie Pie
Applejack
Fluttershy
Mini Sets
Twilight Sparkle
Shining Armor
Princess Cadance
Rainbow Dash
Wonderbolts Pony
Playful Ponies (Order of obtained)
1 Twilight Sparkle Pony Wedding
2 Applejack Suitcase
3 Fluttershy Loose
4 Rarity Pony Wedding
5 Lyra Heartstrings Pony Wedding
6 Twilight Sparkle w/ tiara from Royal Castle Set
7 Cheerilee from Pony School Pals & Cheerilee
8 Sweetie Belle from Pony School Pals & Cheerilee
9 Scootaloo from Pony School Pals & Cheerilee
10 Apple Bloom from Pony School Pals & Cheerilee
11 Rainbow Dash Pony Wedding
12 Pinkie Pie Pony Wedding
13 Trixie Lulamoon Pony Wedding
Fashion Style
1 Fashion Style Pinkie Pie
Other
Princess Celestia from Royal Castle Set