Who is your fave? Open to all gens!

BabyKittenCandy

BabyKittenCandy

Bushwoolie
MLPTP Supporter
Joined
Apr 26, 2019
Messages
8
So, im hoping to get a bit of feedback from the community here. Who cant you resist? Who do you look for on merch and stuff that would make you buy? As I said, open to all gens! Im a Gen 1 girl but I know there is a lot of love for the other gens too!
 
My favorite gens are 1,2, and 3. I love all ponies but those are my favorite. I grew up with all three so they have a special place in my heart. :ponylove:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak
I have a few G2s and G3's but G1's are my fave and the original style of art, but I guess it's because it's the gen I grew up with. Out of the G1's the Big Brothers are my faves, but I only have 4 and don't plan to get any more. I suppose having a few good ones are enough for me, while I have trouble cutting down my want list for the "standard" G1's.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak
G1 here too. It’s what I grew up with and I have a strong nostalgia attached to them. I never was attracted to the other generations but the latest I liked the cartoons. Loved they used Apple Jack
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak
I am a G1 girl for sure (but I do love some FIM especially the cutie mark crusaders)!

Edit:
If we are picking favorites then mine is Firefly as a pony and any merch. I don't really do merch but I would entertain it with Firefly on it. Also I cannot pass up the cuteness of little Scootaloo, she makes me smile every time I see her.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Tak
g3 here, i always search for Silver Glow, Skywishes, Sweet Breeze, Sweetberry and etc. when i search for generation 3 merch. i just love their themes :smile:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak
I’m a g1 at heart. I do love g2, g3, and g4. G5 is growing on me. Not a fan of the g4 reboot and g4.5. G3.5 isn’t my favorite, but still has a place in my collection. I’m such a sucker for purple!
 
Hmm, for g1 if I ever saw merch with Merry Treat I’d totally want it, for g3 I love when I see Star Catcher, Razzaroo or Minty on things and if anything had Fingerpaints it’d be really cool but I never see anything using her
 
Lilykin said:
House on fire, could only grab one mlp from my collection? G1 Birthday Pony, hands down.

I would absolutely get my crummy hands on merch of her if there was any lol.
Click to expand...
House on fire, I will hold the pillow case open and knock ponies in if given a chance! I have my Aussie blossom plush in my bed, so she’ll probably be the first and most likely to make it out, because… kid, dog, and purse first, in that order. ;)
 
Officially, G1 Firefly is the one pony I will basically buy anything with her on it. I am currently in the market for the movie version.

However, G3 Starcatcher is another favorite. And I find myself keeping an eye out for G4 Lyra, though I am not even sure why. I don't know anything about the character, so it must just be that I like the colors and cutie mark.
 
I love G1, because of childhood nostalgia. As a child I never had a genuine My Little Pony but always wanted one and loved the G1 cartoon series. I almost completely missed G2 (I only have McDonald's Princess Silver Swirl), and at the time of G3 I was not really interested in the MLP. G3.5 is the baby generation for me, grew on me a little bit. G4 was strange at first, but I like it.
I think all generations have cute and nice ponies, but what makes G1 my favourite, is the roundy, cute and innocent design. G1 ponies are more pony-like than the later ones. Unlike the G3.5 and above, especially G5, they resemble a horse. And My Little Pony is a line of fantasy toy horses after all.
Favourite ponies, hard to choose. I like ponies in Posey pose and Firefly pose. And the Big Brother ponies.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak
my little pony collector said:
I love all gens but G3 is my favorite
My favorite ponies from each gen are
G1 twist
G2 Princess Crystal
G3 sky wishes
G4 twilight sparkle
G5 Izzy
Click to expand...
After she posted this Mlpc quized me and i passed with flying colors lol the only pony I had trouble with was g2 Princess crystal I couldn't remember her name so I described her hair, body, and cutie mark, and passed the best sister test!

Oh and the best pony of any gen in my opinion is Minty!!!
 
I don’t think I have a single favourite pony. I’m a G3 person but as I only get ponies from charity shops like a treasure hunt, my G4 collection is growing. Pinkie Pie is the one pony who keeps cropping up in my collection (I actually got me another Pinkie today unexpectedly) but I love Rainbow Dash too who also is dotted about the collection as well. She’s in both my childhood collection and ‘reboot’ collection (the collection I started again during the end of my college years).

I don’t really collect pony merch but if it was something like a badge or keyring I’d love some of my favourite G3s: Sunny Daze, Starcatcher, Minty
or G4: Vinyl Scratch/DJ PON3, Rainbow Dash, Applejack
 
Snuzzle,
Clever Clover
Velvet Bow,
Gingerbread
Pinkie Pie
Princess Silverswirl
G3 Pinkie Pie
Moondancer,
Autumn Sky
Fizzy
G4 Rarity
G2 Moondancer
Light Heart
Bouquet
Sunny Daze
Pillow Talk
Star Hopper
Izzy Moonbow
Tiny Bubbles
Sea Spray
Bubbles
Garden Wishes
Sky Skimmer
Prince Firefly
Tex
Brights Brightly
Barnacle
Dainty Dove
Ringlets
Chief

Until recently I was a G1 snob. Now I love them all! And yes I really have this many favorites..

My first (that I owned) of each gen: CF Snuzzle, one row of hair Clever Clover, Autumn Sky (packaged with Minty), Rarity, Izzy (unicorn party)
 
my favorite gens are g1 and g3, i love them both pretty equally. as for favorite ponies...i love anything that has to do with blossom, gusty, wysteria, star catcher, silver glow, g3 moondancer...

i'm a bit obsessed with purple, gray, and blue ponies. i find myself drawn towards any g4 merch with trixie just because of how much i love her design!
 
Picking one absolute favorite from every gen and almost every species

G1:
Unicorn -Fizzy
Pegasus -Masquerade
Earth Pony-Ice Crystal
Sea Pony-Baby Sea Shimmer
Flutter Pony-Tropical Breeze
Winger-Cool Breeze

G2:
Earth Pony-Eve
Unicorn-Copper Glow

G3:
Earth Pony-Tropical Surprise
Pegasus-Star Catcher
Unicorn-Sunrise Song

G4:
Unicorn -Starlight Glimmer
Pegasus-Merry May
Earth Pony-Sapphire Joy
Unipeg-Princess Sterling
Merpony-Baby Lily Drop
The Bat Pony

Mishmash:
Unicorn-SDCC Twilight
Pegasus-Fluttershy
Earth Pony-Peggy Mane

G5: It's a little too early, since we've gotten so few new toys that aren't Core 5 but I do have one favorite pegasus so far.
Pegasus-Shutter Snap

Hoping to see proper toys of Thunder, Sugar Moonlight, Green Pegasus, Goldie Fortune, Isla Breeze, Sunset Sherbert. (Give us Trailblazer with actual hair you cheapskates!)
 
Wellll if I was going to pick specific favorites... I think per gen lemme pick a few but these arent all of them
G1
Bow Tie
Chocolate Delight
Medley
Bubbles
Baby Ember
Chuck E Cheese

G2
Ivy
Light Heart
Cupcake
Berry Bright
Sundance/Sunsparkle
Prince Firefly (why is he so hard to get! :cry: )

G3
Butterscotch
Wysteria
Citrus Sweetheart
Cupcake
Daisyjo
BowTie
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top