Who Are Your Rarest Ponies?

CocoChipooRocks

Animator Pegasus Pony
Joined
Apr 15, 2013
Messages
348
Awards
0
Hi all! Since Christmas is coming up, I've been looking at my collection inventory and wishlists a lot more than usual, and it got me thinking: I don't always consider buying HTF ponies a priority (I usually just go for ones that I like visually), but it's definitely a factor for some of the ones I've gotten and those I want to buy. Do you have any HTF, sought-after or rare ponies in your collections? Feel free to include Nirvanas or international exclusives!

G1:
Baby Princess Sparkle
Birthflower Ponies (complete set)
Goldilocks
My Pretty Pony (brown)
Yum Yum (TAF)

G3:
Anchors Away
Peachie Keen
Port-O-Bella

Also feel free to take your own consideration on what's rare/HTF! I had some that I removed because I wasn't sure if they were really hard enough to find, but I might add them back in depending on what the consensus is.
 
Last edited:

Leave a Whisper

Local Ding-Bat
  • 5,000 Messages
Joined
Jun 25, 2014
Messages
5,821
Awards
1
Earth Ponies:
Baby Drummer
Port-o-bella
Pearly Sapphire Joy
Baby Racer

Unicorns:
Dazzle Glow
MO Star Hopper
Pearly Sea Swirl
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Tak

nessa16

Nurse Pony
Joined
May 13, 2010
Messages
235
Awards
0
Takara Baby Popo
Greek Baby Minty
Argie Sprinkles
Venny AJ MIB
Berrytown family
Sunbright Family
Baby Sugarcake
Piggy Snuzzle
Greek Lambaditsa
TAF babies
Lil Sweetcake
Mimic
Ice Crystal
Baby Lollipop
Red Roses
Scribbles
Brazilian Sugarberry
Spanish Sugarberry
Peruvian Baby Medley
My Pretty Pony - brown and Peachy

I have more usually listed HTF, etc but these stick out the most for me.
 

Skybreeze

80s Glam Rock Pony
MLPTP Supporter
  • 1,000 Messages
  • MLPTP Bronze Level Supporter
Joined
Oct 18, 2017
Messages
1,921
Awards
2
To be honest, I don’t know what actually rare or hard to find anymore (short of the obvious Rapunzel) vs very sought after like Mimic.

I do have in my G1:
- Baby Drummer
- Baby Twirly Whirly
- Baby Racer
- Baby Drummer
- Baby Princess Sparkle
- Baby Paradise
- MO Tux & Tails
- MO Baby Lucky (I dont
- NSS Shady
- NSS Wind Whistler
- My Pretty Pony
- MO Pearlized Baby Moondancer
- MO Pearlized Baby Blossom
- MO Pearlized Baby Firefly
- MO Pearlized Baby Cotton Candy
- MO Pearlized Baby Surprise
- MO Birthflower (January, February and another one I can’t remember which)
- Softies (Windy, Lickety Split, Lofty & Baby Lofty)

G2:
- Prince Clover (not sure how rare he actually is)

G4:
- Ploomette
- Diamond Tiara
- Twisty
- Star Dreams
- Fluttershy FS 1st wave
- Pinkie Valentines Day MOC
- Fluttershy Easter MOC
- Nurse Redheart MOC (Walgreen’s exclusive)
- All About Starlight Glimmer MOC
- Chicken Pinkie Pie SDCC exclusive
- Retro 80’s Vibe RD, Pinkie & Twlight SDCC exclusive set
- Maniac & Humdrum SDCC exclusive

I probably have more, I just don’t know whose actually sought after or not. I buy mostly what I like, what is a good deal OR Pegasus & Unicorns for G1’s.
 

Tak

Keeping my head in the clouds
MLPTP Supporter
  • 1,000 Messages
  • MLPTP Silver Level Supporter
Joined
Dec 26, 2015
Messages
2,796
Awards
2
I have an Italian blossom and a peacock dark horse custom... plus a very mint pearlized baby blossom. My collection has changed so much from the beginning. I used to have some Greeks, Argentinas, three variations of starglow, all the ff cp, all the wingers, Hollywood, mimic, all the pearlized babies, and about 95% of the g3's. I even held rapunzel for a short time. My priorities had to change. Such is life, right? :flutter2:
 

Caseysealia

Flat Foot Peachy
  • 500 Messages
Joined
Apr 21, 2019
Messages
615
Awards
1
Tux n Tails
Sweet Blossom
Night Glider
Caribbean Delight
My Pretty Pony brown with spot variation
Barnacle
Tex with hat
Non-So-Soft Shady
Secret Star
Autumn Crisp
Tip Toes with tutu
I guess I don't know who's actually rare or not, but these are the rarest in my collection as of now.
 

canadianponycollector

Teeny Tiny Baby Pony
Joined
Jun 29, 2019
Messages
50
Awards
0
g1:
Mail order rapunzel
Mountain boy Tornado
Mimic [Really baity but still]
Two mexican ponies [Blossom and a hair colour variant of cotton candy]

g3:
thistle whistle

G4:
Chinese new year toys r us exclusive pinkie pie
 

dakotadarkhooves

Dollar Store Baby Fakie
Joined
Jun 17, 2015
Messages
149
Awards
0
In terms of value, G3 Rosey Posey is probably the rarest in my collection currently <3

G1:
Baby Dancing Butterflies
Mountain Boy Sunburst
Mexican Prince Sapphire
Mexican Prince Emerald
Mexican Prince Ruby
Italian Tickle

(I don't know how rare TAFs are but I also have near-mint Dancing Butterflies and Love Melody)

G2:
Prince Firefly

G3:
Rosey Posey
Royal Beauty
Pretty Palace
Surf Star

G4:
Twinkleshine w/saddle
Applejack (Brushable) - Forelock version (I think she's considered HTF? Not sure!)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak

Wind~Whistler

So Soft Batter Pony
  • 1,000 Messages
Joined
Sep 18, 2014
Messages
3,836
Awards
1
The few that come to mind are Thistle Whistle (scented), G4 Diamond Rose, and my MIB Winters...


Oh, and the “oh so rare” Pinkie Pie everyone on eBay tries to sell as HTF :rolleyespony:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak

Tak

Keeping my head in the clouds
MLPTP Supporter
  • 1,000 Messages
  • MLPTP Silver Level Supporter
Joined
Dec 26, 2015
Messages
2,796
Awards
2
The few that come to mind are Thistle Whistle (scented), G4 Diamond Rose, and my MIB Winters...


Oh, and the “oh so rare” Pinkie Pie everyone on eBay tries to sell as HTF :rolleyespony:
Which pinkie pie? I'm so curious. Btw, is it just me, or are prices ridiculously high right now?
 

Wind~Whistler

So Soft Batter Pony
  • 1,000 Messages
Joined
Sep 18, 2014
Messages
3,836
Awards
1
Which pinkie pie? I'm so curious. Btw, is it just me, or are prices ridiculously high right now?
Ah no, the Pinkie part was a joke o_O you know, the G4 one no one seems to get rid of?
2F520FE9-5502-47E8-98E6-6947E3D1ACE2.jpeg
:p

And yeah, the prices seem too high as of lately. Currently have an eBay gift card I thought could use on a couple of G3s, but couldn’t justify spending it all on about 3 commons :(
It might be mainly because of the holidays and people trying to declutter though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak

Tak

Keeping my head in the clouds
MLPTP Supporter
  • 1,000 Messages
  • MLPTP Silver Level Supporter
Joined
Dec 26, 2015
Messages
2,796
Awards
2
Ah no, the Pinkie part was a joke o_O you know, the G4 one no one seems to get rid of?
View attachment 27220
:p

And yeah, the prices seem too high as of lately. Currently have an eBay gift card I thought could use on a couple of G3s, but couldn’t justify spending it all on about 3 commons :(
It might be mainly because of the holidays and people trying to declutter though.
That pinkie pie! I think I gave several away! Oh, no! :rudolph: All those rare ponies, gone! :lolpony:
 

Cactusflower

Pied Piper of Ponies
MLPTP Supporter
  • MLPTP Bronze Level Supporter
  • 500 Messages
Joined
Jan 20, 2018
Messages
501
Awards
2
Many years of collecting.

Scribbles
Dabble
Mimic
Munchy
TAF Buttons
TAF baby Love Melody
Tux
Satin N Lace
Magenta Satin N Lace
Lightning
Sunburst
Fireball
Ice Crystal
Two Rollerskating ponies
One Hairdo pony
Lil Sweetcake
All MO pearly babies
Baby Sploosh
All MO sparkle ponies
Nightglider
Jenny
A bunch of Mexican ponies
A few Italians
A few Brazilians
White Cap
Sand Dollar

There are probably more, but those are the ones I could think of off the top of my head
 

Tak

Keeping my head in the clouds
MLPTP Supporter
  • 1,000 Messages
  • MLPTP Silver Level Supporter
Joined
Dec 26, 2015
Messages
2,796
Awards
2
Many years of collecting.

Scribbles
Dabble
Mimic
Munchy
TAF Buttons
TAF baby Love Melody
Tux
Satin N Lace
Magenta Satin N Lace
Lightning
Sunburst
Fireball
Ice Crystal
Two Rollerskating ponies
One Hairdo pony
Lil Sweetcake
All MO pearly babies
Baby Sploosh
All MO sparkle ponies
Nightglider
Jenny
A bunch of Mexican ponies
A few Italians
A few Brazilians
White Cap
Sand Dollar

There are probably more, but those are the ones I could think of off the top of my head
N-i-i-i-ce! Do you know have many you had at the peak of your collecting? I had a total of 2000+ at one point. Before I could let go of all those slight variations.
 

Cactusflower

Pied Piper of Ponies
MLPTP Supporter
  • MLPTP Bronze Level Supporter
  • 500 Messages
Joined
Jan 20, 2018
Messages
501
Awards
2
N-i-i-i-ce! Do you know have many you had at the peak of your collecting? I had a total of 2000+ at one point. Before I could let go of all those slight variations.
I’m still peaking :)

With all gens I have maybe 1000-1200 I guess. If I include my doubles that I need to sell, maybe 2000. Just kidding, but I have about 250 for sale.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak

mexicanmlp

Dollar Store Baby Fakie
Joined
Mar 4, 2015
Messages
354
Awards
0
G1s (the ones that first came to mind):
Mimic, Cha Cha the llama and Oakley the Moose, Cutesaurus, Tux 'n Tails, Dabble & Scribbles, Li'l Cupcake & Li'l Sweetcake, MO Mommy, Baby Gametime.

Nirvanas:
All my Mexicans! Especially my fakie boys.
Greek: Moonstone.
Brazil: Shy Bubbles.
Peru: Glory (despite being almost baity).
German: Raindrop.

G2s:
Spanish Seabreeze.

G3s:
Some art/convention ponies (white pony -the standard, small one-, Pony Project White, Junko Mizuno, Twinkle Hope, etc.).
Beach Belle & Caribbean Delight.

G4s:
I don't think I have something particular nice.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak
Top