$ Price Check $ !!!UPDATED!!! Deluxe 18 Piece Cookie Making & Decorating Kit 100% Complete

[wart]

*************7Nov edited to add

I have a rare piece of merch I wonder if you lovelies could price for me?

This is the My Little Pony Baby Pony Deluxe 18 piece Cookie Making & Decorating Kit, and it is 100% complete. (Even has 20 year old cookie gunk in it maybe? I will definitely clean before sale.) The box is in bad condition, it has old tape on it as well, faded, torn, all that jazz.

any guesses? It doesn’t sell often so I’m not sure what is fair.

https://imgur.com/a/opvNmdB

*************original post below

Hi! I’m going to be selling my entire collection of all MLP and related AND unrelated toys and collectibles! It’s going to take me at least a year, so I will be looking for price checks and sales advice periodically, since I’ve been out of collecting for quite a while and I need the guidance of the experts! I’ll use imgur for the pics.

Celebration Castle

https://imgur.com/a/qCBJBqL

This is 100% complete but not all of that is pictured, it also is the version that includes two baby ponies, pink subsparkle and romperooni. It has the box and instructions, and if you look at the back of the box, the pony points are cut out so that the lucky buyer can simulate for themselves how it feels, firsthand, to be unable to collect enough pony points for giant plush frilly frocks before they sell out! I included a pic of the battery compartment for condition.

Walmart plush group

https://imgur.com/a/LGRci7E

I want to require something I sell to be worth at a minimum 5$ before I sell it individually rather than in a lot. These all have their tags, like new condition, what do you think? A lot or individuals, and how much depending?

I have an ENORMOUS backcard and paper merch lot, and this is approximately 1/8th of it.

https://imgur.com/a/cXo8R0d

The posters and blue bags on the right bottom are the mail order g3 posters with their envelopes and inserts and the bags and inserts that the mail order ponies came in. I could match them with the mail order ponies...but I don’t wanna. I feel like I need to move this along and some collector can have them with their mail order ponies.

There are 5 My Little Pony magazines, 5 Sparkle World magazines (2 dupes), 5 Hasbro catalogs, the two books by the catalogs include read along cds with songs, the middle left birthday card makes noise, I think it’s pinkie pie talking, the birthday card by the G1 coloring book(new and uncolored, good condition) has writing in it(the card does)

I am tempted to sell this as a single paper goods lot. Talk to me, oh Pony Gurus!

 

[MustBeJewel]

I've heard a little buzz this past year about the Celebration Castle, but what's going to get you is the shipping, unfortunately. Taking a look at Ebay, I'd say that complete with box, you may be looking at about $75 or so, but I'd expect that to go up as we approach the holidays: https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_fr...castle&_sacat=0&rt=nc&LH_Sold=1&LH_Complete=1

I haven't had much luck selling the Funrise plush in the past, and the mane 6 characters are usually less appealing to buyers. Here's how I'd price them, with flexibility in mind:

Rarity: $8
Pinkie Pie: $5
Octavia: $10
Rainbow Dash: $8

As for the paper goods, the G2 backcard may be worth about $3-4, G3 reading books $1, books of G3 stickers $3-4 each, the G1 coloring book as much as $8-10.

I'm not sure on the rest, but I hope that helps for now

 

[wart]

I've heard a little buzz this past year about the Celebration Castle, but what's going to get you is the shipping, unfortunately. Taking a look at Ebay, I'd say that complete with box, you may be looking at about $75 or so, but I'd expect that to go up as we approach the holidays: https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_fr...castle&_sacat=0&rt=nc&LH_Sold=1&LH_Complete=1

I haven't had much luck selling the Funrise plush in the past, and the mane 6 characters are usually less appealing to buyers. Here's how I'd price them, with flexibility in mind:

Rarity: $8
Pinkie Pie: $5
Octavia: $10
Rainbow Dash: $8

As for the paper goods, the G2 backcard may be worth about $3-4, G3 reading books $1, books of G3 stickers $3-4 each, the G1 coloring book as much as $8-10.

I'm not sure on the rest, but I hope that helps for now

Thank you Is it possible that the Celebration Castle might be one of the things better sold in person, or would the advantage of that not really be enough to make not paying shipping worth it? (Did that come out weird?)

 

[Gingerbread]

I have that baking set, I bought mine several years ago and if I recall correctly I think I paid about 50.-75. for it. Not sure about it's current price but that might help give you an idea??

 

[wart]

I have that baking set, I bought mine several years ago and if I recall correctly I think I paid about 50.-75. for it. Not sure about it's current price but that might help give you an idea??

THANK YOU! It does very much actually, I wouldn’t have known to start an auction for it at 8$ or 80$. I found it secondhand for 2$ which doesn’t educate me. I think I will start it around 35$ possibly and see if it goes (I like to start auctions as close to their end point as possible lately). I need to find a good box for it, too, it’s quite fragile. Possibly ship it without the pieces inside to rattle around and get lost.

 

[MustBeJewel]

I'd say the baking set is easily over $100 nowadays An auction is a great idea though, I think you'll get a great price for it! As far as shipping, as long as you wrap each item carefully and fill every single void in the box with peanuts or bubble wrap you'll be fine

 

[wart]

I'd say the baking set is easily over $100 nowadays An auction is a great idea though, I think you'll get a great price for it! As far as shipping, as long as you wrap each item carefully and fill every single void in the box with peanuts or bubble wrap you'll be fine

I had it up on ebay and it did not sell, which makes me super glad I set the price so high, because I believe that what killed it was the shipping. I think this item might be a good candidate for the MD Pony Meet auction. What do you think? Safer than having to ship it, and less expensive, and it’s the kind of thing the veteran pros at the MD meet might still be hunting for.

 

[MustBeJewel]

I think that's a great idea!! It's a really unique item and I think it'll draw a lot of interest in person, where no one has to worry about shipping