Hello all, here is my fairly comprehensive wishlist! I'm pretty sure I've sorted everything properly but if anything seems out of place, just let me know!
G1
1983
Earth Ponies
Bowtie
1984
Earth Ponies
Lickety Split
1985
Flutter Ponies
Rosedust
So Soft Ponies
Cherries Jubilee
Cupcake
Twinkle-Eyed Ponies
Sweet Pop
Fizzy
1986
Baby Ponies
Baby Crumpet
Earth Ponies
Scoops
Princess Ponies
Princess Serena
So Soft Ponies
Crumpet
Twice as Fancy Ponies
Sugarberry
Sweet Tooth
Twinkle-Eyed Ponies
Locket
1987
Magic Message Ponies
Mirror Mirror
Cloud Dreamer
Princess Ponies
Princess Misty
Princess Dawn
Sweetberry Ponies
Raspberry Jam
Boysenberry Pie
Blueberry Baskets
Strawberry Surprise
Cranberry Muffins
Cherry Treats
Sundae Best Ponies
Banana Surprise
Peppermint Crunch
Sherbet
Twice as Fancy Ponies
Merriweather
Yum Yum
Buttons
1988
Candy Cane Ponies
Lemon Treats
Mint Dreams
Sugar Apple
Sugar Sweet
Merry-Go-Round Ponies
Sunnybunch
Flower Bouquet
Tassles
Perfume Puff Ponies
Red Roses
Lavender Lace
1989
Baby Ponies
Baby Princess Sparkle
Rainbow Curl Ponies
Ringlet
Raincurl
Streaky
Stripes
Tropical Ponies
Hula Hula
Pina Colada
Tootie Tails
1990
Baby Rainbow Ponies
Baby Rainribbon
Baby Brightbow
Baby Starbow
Baby Sunribbon
Princess Ponies
Princess Royal Purple
Princess Royal Pink
1991
Soda Sippin Ponies
Chocolate Delight
Strawberry Scoops
G3
2004
Tea Leaf
Cinnamon Breeze
Cupcake
Cherry Blossom
Triple Treat
Rainbow Flash
Lickity Split
Port-o-Bella
Desert Rose
Peachy Pie
Rainbow Swirl
2005
Butter Drop
Bowtie
Coconut Cream
Kiwi Tart
Strawberry Sunset
Fantastical February
Guava Lava
Cotton Candy
Strawberry Reef
Island Rainbow
Apple Spice
Coconut Grove
Pineapple Paradise
Rainbowberry
2006
February Violet
June Rose
Sweet Sparkle
Blushie
Cute Curtsey
Chocolate Delight
Royal Rose
Crowning Glory
Tira-Mi-Su
Peach Surprise
Berries n Cherries
2007
Swirlypop
Chocolate Chipper
Party Cake
Pretty Pop
Soda Float
Strawberry Surprise
Rainbow Bubbles
G4
2011
Cupcake
Thanks for looking!
G1
1983
Earth Ponies
Bowtie
1984
Earth Ponies
Lickety Split
1985
Flutter Ponies
Rosedust
So Soft Ponies
Cherries Jubilee
Cupcake
Twinkle-Eyed Ponies
Sweet Pop
Fizzy
1986
Baby Ponies
Baby Crumpet
Earth Ponies
Scoops
Princess Ponies
Princess Serena
So Soft Ponies
Crumpet
Twice as Fancy Ponies
Sugarberry
Sweet Tooth
Twinkle-Eyed Ponies
Locket
1987
Magic Message Ponies
Mirror Mirror
Cloud Dreamer
Princess Ponies
Princess Misty
Princess Dawn
Sweetberry Ponies
Raspberry Jam
Boysenberry Pie
Blueberry Baskets
Strawberry Surprise
Cranberry Muffins
Cherry Treats
Sundae Best Ponies
Banana Surprise
Peppermint Crunch
Sherbet
Twice as Fancy Ponies
Merriweather
Yum Yum
Buttons
1988
Candy Cane Ponies
Lemon Treats
Mint Dreams
Sugar Apple
Sugar Sweet
Merry-Go-Round Ponies
Sunnybunch
Flower Bouquet
Tassles
Perfume Puff Ponies
Red Roses
Lavender Lace
1989
Baby Ponies
Baby Princess Sparkle
Rainbow Curl Ponies
Ringlet
Raincurl
Streaky
Stripes
Tropical Ponies
Hula Hula
Pina Colada
Tootie Tails
1990
Baby Rainbow Ponies
Baby Rainribbon
Baby Brightbow
Baby Starbow
Baby Sunribbon
Princess Ponies
Princess Royal Purple
Princess Royal Pink
1991
Soda Sippin Ponies
Chocolate Delight
Strawberry Scoops
G3
2004
Tea Leaf
Cinnamon Breeze
Cupcake
Cherry Blossom
Triple Treat
Rainbow Flash
Lickity Split
Port-o-Bella
Desert Rose
Peachy Pie
Rainbow Swirl
2005
Butter Drop
Bowtie
Coconut Cream
Kiwi Tart
Strawberry Sunset
Fantastical February
Guava Lava
Cotton Candy
Strawberry Reef
Island Rainbow
Apple Spice
Coconut Grove
Pineapple Paradise
Rainbowberry
2006
February Violet
June Rose
Sweet Sparkle
Blushie
Cute Curtsey
Chocolate Delight
Royal Rose
Crowning Glory
Tira-Mi-Su
Peach Surprise
Berries n Cherries
2007
Swirlypop
Chocolate Chipper
Party Cake
Pretty Pop
Soda Float
Strawberry Surprise
Rainbow Bubbles
G4
2011
Cupcake
Thanks for looking!