So who was your first childhood pony?

[Candice88]

My very first ponies were Baby Starbow and movie version Firefly. I got them for Christmas just before I turned 4. I took them absolutely everywhere and I still have them. I could never give them up!

 

[evilbunnyfoofoo]

Ooh! You got a pic of her? I must see this brave and daring pony

Yes, Skeen! Let us get a gander at your grizzled war veteran!

 

[starbeam]

I never had a MLP when I was wee, but I should just ask Quackers which was it since I forgot. Again

 

[TARDISGirl78]

the first one i rmeember buying myself was baby glory.

i was paid to do six week taste test of lemon lime soda

 

[Elfpony]

I believe it was Cotton Candy. Yeah I know that proves how old I am. I was super happy when the ponies first came out. I still remember it as a sweet memory. I also remember later getting a cotton candy plushie softie. I still have yet to buy one. I never get around to things like this its my fault. My mother bought Cotton Candy or at least thats what I believe.

Yes, Cotton Candy was my first too. I remember my mom getting her for me at a now-defunct department store, Towers. I picked her because she was pink, and I was five, and a pink pony marketed to little girls in the 80s was like a license to print money. And the next day we were back again and I got Blossom to be her best friend. Don't remember why I got two toys in two days, that wasn't a norm, but I was quite sick as a young child, so that may have had something to do with it. Bribery will still work on me. ;P

Elf

 

[Skycakes]

Yes, Cotton Candy was my first too. I remember my mom getting her for me at a now-defunct department store, Towers. I picked her because she was pink, and I was five, and a pink pony marketed to little girls in the 80s was like a license to print money. And the next day we were back again and I got Blossom to be her best friend. Don't remember why I got two toys in two days, that wasn't a norm, but I was quite sick as a young child, so that may have had something to do with it. Bribery will still work on me. ;P

Elf

I also got Blossom as a second pony. That is strange. I really wanted Blue Belle and Minty but I never got those two. I did get the Dream Castle when I had to go to the doctor for some tests. I still remember that thing. I am happy I have a new one now. The window kinda broke off on one side but I tried fixing it. :/

 

[starbeam]

It was McStarsong back in 2008 When the Core Seven thing was going on. I didn't know it upset many collectors, but I wouldn't be here if it wasn't for them! Her feet was full of red PlayDoh since I thought she was also a stamper. I now have my original and an upgrade.

But my first ACTUAL Pony was G3.5 Newborn Cuties Cheerilee and bathtub, and a "Normal" Cheerilee. How funny I used to hate that pony, since I actually only wanted SLH Rainbow Dash (Never got her :c) or "TAF" Toola Roola (Which I got for my birthday that year, lol)

~Baby Quackers

 

[h1m3.]

I think my first pony was Melody. I still remember when I got her and when I opened her box

 

[Marble Dragon]

Man, I can't remember my very first pony! I was barely walking when I got my first pony. Probably sea spray baby seapony. Or maybe chief or coco berry.

 

[Harmony Rain]

My first pony was Sundance: my mom got me the special set with Megan for my birthday when I was little. I was probably like 4 or 5 since I actually do remember opening the package lol. Or rather begging my dad to open it! She remains one of my top faves to this day. ^^

 

[Philly]

I remember having a blue pegasus or unicorn when I was very, very little. I think it had stars on it's bum and it was probably a fakie. No idea what happened to her

 

[bluerose9978]

I believe it was Cotton Candy. Yeah I know that proves how old I am. I was super happy when the ponies first came out. I still remember it as a sweet memory. I also remember later getting a cotton candy plushie softie. I still have yet to buy one. I never get around to things like this its my fault. My mother bought Cotton Candy or at least thats what I believe.

Yes, Cotton Candy was my first too. I remember my mom getting her for me at a now-defunct department store, Towers. I picked her because she was pink, and I was five, and a pink pony marketed to little girls in the 80s was like a license to print money. And the next day we were back again and I got Blossom to be her best friend. Don't remember why I got two toys in two days, that wasn't a norm, but I was quite sick as a young child, so that may have had something to do with it. Bribery will still work on me. ;P
Elf

My first pony was Cotton Candy, as well! And I think I must have been around 3 or 4 years old and it must have been a Christmas gift because my sister got a pony, too. She got Bowtie. But, then again, my dad was known for going out of town on for his job, and when did, he brought my sister and I a toy. So we could have gotten them during one of his trips. At first, he brought us both ponies on his trips. But when my sister started getting a little older, she started getting into barbies, so it would be a pony for me and a barbie for her or it would be a barbie for her and a barbie horse or Fashion Star Filly for me...LOL! He kind of went back and forth on what kind of toys to get us, but we always got great toys! We really looked forward to him coming home from his business trips!

 

[Philly]

The very first G1(s) I got were Moonstone and Princess Dawn. They're both super nice but it took some work to tame Princess Dawn's tinsel!
For so many years (through G3) I wanted a pony so badly but I wasn't allowed to have one, something about them drew me to them and I still can't pinpoint exactly why I like them so much.

 

[starbeam]

I remember having a blue pegasus or unicorn when I was very, very little. I think it had stars on it's bum and it was probably a fakie. No idea what happened to her

Do you mean Starflower or Sunbeam? They are blue unis and have celestial symbols

 

[Philly]

Do you mean Starflower or Sunbeam? They are blue unis and have celestial symbols

I'm fairly certain she was more like, Rainbow Dash baby blue color. Honestly, the closest thing I can find is this

I was so so small that even if I saw her again, I wouldn't remember her. My only memories are of a very vague baby blue unicorn or pegasus, I'm certain she was either a unicorn or a pegasus and I'm think she was a fakie found at like a garage sale or something

 

[icecreamgirl]

My first pony was Bluebelle

I loved that pony so much!

 

[Maude pie]

My first pony was Greek Butterscotch. I remember the day my mom bought it for me and a Cotton Candy for my sister!
It is my most precious pony after all these years.

 

[littledreamer]

My first was a Sugarberry my mom gave me out of her childhood ponies(yeah for young mommies). My true "first" I'd like to think was the Minty I bought back in 2003 in Target with A Charming Birthday tape. I was nine, it felt like the happiest day in my life. My ponies had came back!

 

[Trilliumfairy]

All this reading about everyone's ponies started me thinking about my very first pony. It was Posey, I got her at Toyworld in little Westport here in New Zealand on a family trip


Do you all remember your first pony too and when you got them?
I'd love to know please

Hey! Mine was Posey too! I got her for either my birthday or for Christmas (not sure which). After that, I was hooked! She's still my favorite though.

 

[RedTabbyKitty]

It sounds like Posey has a lot to answer for

Love your name too by the way, I keep meaning to find a safe shady spot in my garden for some trillium's since I first saw them