G4 Price Check - Warning Lots of Ponies

Moondream

Moondream

Celestial Pony Lover
Joined
Aug 16, 2014
Messages
1,014
I'm so sorry to ask this! I need help pricing some of my ponies I'd like to sell. They are all out of package.

Equestria girls Twilight Sparkle. I believe she is the original one. She doesn't have accessories.
Wedding Castle. Missing the two pieces of furniture. Everything else is there
FS Celestia. Has crown
FS Twlight. Has Crown
Version 1 FS Apple Jack. No accessories.
Twilight Sparkle Figure. Unicorn no tinsel in hair
Twlight Sparkle. Tinsel in hair
Lyra figure
Derpy Hooves Figure
Diamond Tiara Figure
Princess Cadence figure - Wedding Outfit
Celestia+Pinkie Pie McDonald's from the latest wave
RC Wedding Car+Controller.

Again I'm very sorry to ask all this. I've tried to check google and I've been getting a lot of mixed results. G4 is not my expertise :sadpony:
 
It is not mine either, though I would be pleased to research for you based on previous ~6 months ebay sold items. :D
I shall come back and edit this one


Equestria girls Twilight Sparkle. I believe she is the original one. She doesn't have accessories. $8- $10
Wedding Castle. Missing the two pieces of furniture. Everything else is there $25-$30
FS Celestia. Has crown $8-$10
FS Twlight. Has Crown $10-$12
 
That would be so wonderful! Thank you!! =)
 
A few of them I was able to easily look up, the rest I am uncertain as there are many that could be the same. Lets wait for a G4 collector to come along, rather than me give you incorrect info. I found loads of Twilight, derpy, and Lyra figures, I was lost as to which ones LOL....
 
The figures are just the brushables. Thank you so much for taking the time to try to help me! I my love MLP but I find it so annoying to have to monitor the prices from four different gens. :lolpony:
 
It's funny you say that. I bought the wedding castle today with 20 G4/G1 ponies for 30 today. That's why I'd like to sell it :lolpony: Thanks for giving me an idea of the price!
 
I can give you opinions based on what I collect, but I don't consider myself an expert at this...

I bought the wedding castle for $30 new locally, so I'd assume that without the box or ponies and only missing furniture it would be about $18ish? It would be worth about $20 complete without ponies. I figure a decent price for the castle on its own is $10-$15, highly dependant on its condition. I don't know how fast these things discolour, and G4 stickers are notoriously... unsticky.

Princess Cadance, I'd say she's about $6 at most, due to the number of times she's been re-released. She's worth about that much new in the set with Applejack. I'm not sure how much extra you could charge for her with the dress... perhaps $1 more? I'd probably just stick her with the castle and charge a bit more for it, provided that it's in good condition. Then the only thing it's missing besides the furniture is Shining Armor.

I don't collect Fashion Style ponies, but I DO know that FS Applejack is highly sought after. She'd probably be at least $20 on her own. I would go with what Slinky said and price the other two at around $10 each.

The mane 6 ponies are pretty much worthless, people buy them new to use as bait because they're so overproduced and easily obtainable. I'd say the Twilight Sparkles would go for about $3 each, irrespective of tinsel.

The last three are all from the TRU Favourites collection, it's still available in stores. Lyra's had a few releases now, so I don't think she's worth more than maybe $5. Diamond Tiara is $5-6. Derpy is $10-12, as this was her only release.

You could possibly mark down these prices further, as all of this is going by NM values. If you could post photos or list any flaws, perhaps someone could give you more details.
 
I've seen FS Applejack go for about $40-50 on her own. She's about to have another release in the FS, so I'd try to sell her fast before the second version brings down her price.

I'd say most of lady's prices are spot on, really.
 
If you're going to be selling, I may be interested in your Derpy and Diamond Tiara... :cool: *Puts hands in trench coat pockets.*
 
Oh wait, we were supposed to tell Moondream that her Ponies are all The Yuck and worthless. In fact, she should pay us to take them off her hands! LOL!



Joking aside, the McD's toys are going for about $3 packaged and $1 loose for Pinkie. Celestia seems to be getting more, at $5 packaged, $3 loose. They're loose. Wink wink. HAHA.

The car is getting at least $20 that i can see, with people asking as much as 35 (but they're not selling at that price).

You sure got a great deal. I've only lucked out on craigslist once.
 
Oh gosh thank you so very much everyone! It's so kind of you to take the time to help me out =)

@ladyofthenight I'm glad you know so much about G4! I'd be so lost without your prices. Sadly I'm attached to Derpy now. Her lazy eyes grew on me. :lolpony: I'd be happy to sell you Diamond Tiara! I'll post pics in just a bit. They don't have any flaws. (hair is soft, silky, no symbol rub, no marks on their bodies, no dents and dings.)

Actually it's funny. The woman I bought them from bought all these ponies for her daughter. Hundreds of dollars with of ponies. She gave them to her daughter who flat our refused them. The little one only wanted 'lego ponies' which are the blind bags. The other ponies went to her son who is a HUGE MLP fan and the rest to craigstlist.

@evilbunnyfoofoo What a sneaky tactic! Sneaky but good :lolpony:

Alright thank you for all the prices! I think I'll sell the car with Twilight Sparkle for around $25. I'm so glad I have so many G4 savvy friends!

Honestly Craigslist doesn't usually work with me. I've been checking for 2 months and this is my first find!
 
DSCF7632_zps104efc0b.jpg


This was the lot I got from Craiglist in case anyone was wondering. Like I said the ponies are all in condition. The only flaw is Night Bright has her forlock cut and someone dipped Rainbow Dash in a candle. I wont be selling them so that's not a big deal =)
 
What an awesome lot that is, congrats. :)
@Moondream I have copied the above post along to show and tell.
This is too good to have hidden in a price check thread.
 
Slinky said:
What an awesome lot that is, congrats. :)
@Moondream I have copied the above post along to show and tell.
This is too good to have hidden in a price check thread.
Click to expand...

Thank you so much! That's very kind of you to go the extra mile for me, I really appreciate it =) I'll go check out the show and tell and see what everyone has to say.
 
Moondream said:
I'm glad you know so much about G4! I'd be so lost without your prices. Sadly I'm attached to Derpy now. Her lazy eyes grew on me. :lolpony: I'd be happy to sell you Diamond Tiara! I'll post pics in just a bit. They don't have any flaws. (hair is soft, silky, no symbol rub, no marks on their bodies, no dents and dings.)
Click to expand...

I've been collecting G4s since February and I'm still trying to finish up my collection. I've only started looking at G1s and G2s again now, since I'm battling to find the last G4s that I need and I'm desperate to at least get my hands on something that I want.

I don't blame you with Derpy, it's hard not to fall in love with that face.
527613__safe_solo_animated_derpy+hooves_hub+logo_hubble_hub_flag_spoiler-colon-s04e10_rainbow+falls.gif


I notice in the above photo that you have a Lyrica Lilac that you didn't mention in your price check, though – are you keeping her as well?
 
I try very hard to stay away from G4. I mostly collect G3+G1 and I'm just starting to collect G2. I try to stay away from G4 because I have just to many ponies! However sometimes I just can't say no *tries to hide 3 tubs full of G4 merch* I think I have a bit of a pony problem :blush:*

Derpy is actually the pony that made me really want to collect to G4. Then I saw Luna and I was in love!

She's the purplish grey pony with the necklace? If so then yes. I think of her as Lyra Heartstrings mom :lolpony: The ponies I'm keeping are Rarity, DJ Pon3 Mcdonalds, 1 Cadence, Lilac, Derpy, and Night Bright. The rest are for sale.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top