Most overrated pony

Peppermint Truly

Peppermint Truly

Rockabilly husky tamer
Joined
Jun 10, 2005
Messages
4,435
Have you ever noticed how someone might pay a ton of money for a pony and you just don't even like it? I know a lot of people dislike Mimic, or Rapunzel, and could never see themselves paying the big bucks for them, so this question is about that...

Which pony do you think is highly overrated?
 
I think the most overrated pony is Rapunzel. I don't really like her pose or her colors. I may feel different someday but I think if I was to find her pretty cheap that I'd sell her so that I could buy ponies that I really like.

I think a lot of people get caught up in the hype of getting certain ponies. Kind of like they are status symbols or something.
 
Yeah totally Rapunzel. I really don't like her.

Harmony Share said:
I may feel different someday but I think if I was to find her pretty cheap that I'd sell her so that I could buy ponies that I really like.
Click to expand...

That's what I would do too... I don't care about having ponies I don't like.
 
Mimic is not a very -OMG WOW- pony..! and i think she is the most overated...
She doesn't have anything more than Galaxy or Fizzy :/
Also Diamond Dreams, what does she have that the rest MGR ponies don't? :p

Mario~Gusty
 
I hate to say it.... MB Ice Crystal.
I think he's pretty but, I think the other MB's have cooler color combos.
 
Sweet Scoops. Almost identical to Sundae Best pony Sherbert, only hundreds of dollars more.

Also Rapunzel. She's just blah.
 
oh and some of the exclusive G3s... I'm sorry but the Licencing Show Rarity and Pinkie Pie just are not worth it to me. They look almost exactly like the regular Rarity and Pinkie Pie but are super expensive and hard to find.
 
For me, it's Mimic. I really like the tropical themed ponies for the most part, but despite that, I don't really care for Mimic. I think it's because I don't like her colors. I'm not fond of her shade of green, and I don't really like her hair colors, either. Caribbean Delight is a much prettier parrot symbol pony.
 
You have my three already; Rapunzel, Mimic and Ice Crystal.

But thinking of a new one - Tornado. He just lacks well, va-va-voom. So does Thundercloud.

Now Sunburst and Fireball ARE worth going gagaga over!
 
Lol i agree with both of mariosgustys mimic is soo over rated i think the best twinkle eyed pony was brighteyes cos she was so bright but mimic just doesnt do it for me. still need her to complete my twinkle eyes tho lol.
And Diamond dreams? ive got her but for the amount i paid i baught all the others whats with that? shes so bright and lovelty but come on? better than the others? what eva
 
G3 wise...the Liscensing Show Pinkie Pie & Liscensing Show Rarity. Geeze Louise....I definately don't think I'll ever get LSPP to complete my G3 collection being how ridiculous she cost, & actually I'm fine with that!
 
Baity looking "Nirvana" ponies. Don't care, don't want.
 
I say Rapunzel. Her pose is just bleh and there are other ponies with longest and prettiest hair IMHO.
 
oh uhm... Greek Ladybird? Don't get me wrong... I think she's gorgeous, just not at all worth her pricetag.
 
thebeth said:
oh uhm... Greek Ladybird? Don't get me wrong... I think she's gorgeous, just not at all worth her pricetag.
Click to expand...

Aww, Hank's dog!

Um, yeah, I'd say, any factory pony sold for more than, say, $20. I mean, they aren't even self-propelled or made of precious metals or anything. Starfilght and Heart Bright have movable wings, so that makes them worth $178? Save the money for your psychiatrist. I really did see one for that much on Amazon recently. I'm pretty sure it's gone now cause I can't find it. Which means some sucker probably bought it.

If it was one of you.... WOW, nice buy! :D
 
SerendipityG3A said:
Aww, Hank's dog!

Um, yeah, I'd say, any factory pony sold for more than, say, $20. I mean, they aren't even self-propelled or made of precious metals or anything. Starfilght and Heart Bright have movable wings, so that makes them worth $178? Save the money for your psychiatrist. I really did see one for that much on Amazon recently. I'm pretty sure it's gone now cause I can't find it. Which means some sucker probably bought it.

If it was one of you.... WOW, nice buy! :D
Click to expand...

Amazon is so worthless. You have to look really hard to find reasonably priced ponies on there... However if those prices are accurate... dang those two are overrated too!!! I really hate Heart Bright's pose.
 
thebeth said:
Amazon is so worthless. You have to look really hard to find reasonably priced ponies on there... However if those prices are accurate... dang those two are overrated too!!! I really hate Heart Bright's pose.
Click to expand...

LOL Heart Bright is my favourite of the two! That's okay, you don't have to like it. Hasbro won't make more no matter how many like it. It was a Starflight that was $178, but I still see Heart Bright sometimes priced over 3 times what I'd be willing to pay for the most elaborate, most desired pony.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top