[Heat #25] - Comet Tail VS. Star Flower

[Spoosh]

Oh, we're in the thick of it now. Today's heat decides who will be in the Final 4!

Competing are two very recent ponies: Comet Tail VS. Star Flower.

Comet Tail:

Star Flower:

And below is the system of brackets that will help us follow the competition.

(You can view the past 3 completed Madness brackets here: 2004 competition; 2005 competition; 2006 competition)

 

[Joey Swirl]

i like starflower 8)

 

[cobralily]

go comet! *waves foam finger*

 

[starbritesprinkles]

I like them both, but I prefer Star Flower's pose.

 

[Yuixe]

I really like them both, but I'm going to vote for Comet Tail because of her intense colors and originality.

 

[morning glory77]

I like them both, but Star Flower's pose is better. SF gets my vote this time.

 

[Feral]

Argh, this is such a tough choice because I love them both.

 

[Spooky]

Comet Tail! A nice blend of quality colors. She's pretty in pink, and spacy!

 

[Pink Sunsparkle]

This was a very hard descision for me, as I love both ponies, but I just had to go with Comet Tail. Something about her reminds me of pinky orange sunsets, and I just love the sky when it's pinky orange. It's always so pretty, and since she's a blend of those colors, I went with her. I hope to own her someday!

 

[lev_21n01]

*chants* Star Flower, Star Flower, Star Flower...

 

[Dava]

Star Flower has the better pose, but Comet Tail is just so well put together. I love her sunset colors and I think her symbol is so well designed. And what a great name! So much better than the "Random-Thing Wishes" that Hasbro keeps using for names. If Comet Tail were in the Seaspray pose, she'd be the perfect pony.

 

[SoccerChicka]

Comet Tail, her colours, symbol and name are so original. Don't care for her pose, but she gets my vote.

 

[Tyrseight]

Comet Tail! Her colors are so pretty!

 

[Dancing Butterfly]

Ohhh hard! Both are pretty in different ways. I like the orange gradient in CT, but hate the pose. Love the blue in SF and the green in her mane. Hmmm. SF it is, as CT's pose will never grow on me.

 

[PinkChicken22]

Star Flower is so dull and boring, I mean come on, a flower for a symbol? *Yawn*

 

[tealslippers]

Star Flower all the way - Comet Tail is weird

 

[sam234uk]

Comet tail is more interesting to me.

 

[Reaperfox]

Oh wow. My vote just made it exactly 50/50.

Intense!

 

[SourdoughStomper]

Both are lovely, but I gotta stick with the firey hot pony. ^_^

 

[Sil]

I love them both, but in the end the blue with rainbow hair won over the color gradient. Star Flower just looks kinda fresh too me. And she seems to be somewhat of a tribute to her blue, rainbow-haired G1 name-sake

Sil