[Heat #1] Thistle Whistle Vs. Fairy Dust

Status
Not open for further replies.

Spoosh

Spoosh McSpoosh
Joined
May 26, 2005
Messages
755
In the world of American college basketball, there's this little thing called March Madness, in which teams compete for a championship of some kind. Little is known about this competition, because nobody really cares about it - especially not in the Midwest... ::loud cough::. But what we *do* know is that teams compete via a bracket system, in a series of "heats". The winner of each heat moves on to challenge the winner of a seperate heat - the losers go bye-bye. A good time is had by all. Huzzah.

Several fabled years ago, I thought to myself, I thought: Why not merge the world of basketball with that of Ponies? Imagine it. Dribbling ponies. Basketball players with long, neon-colored hair. Or, more simply: a competiton between G3 ponies in the style of the basketball tournament. And thus March PONY Madness was birthed.

Here's what we'll do, we. Each day, two ponies will compete in a popularity contest in a new thread. MLPTP members can then cast their vote for which of the two they would like to see win the heat. Your reasoning is your own: you can vote however you deem fit.

At the end of 24 hours, the pony with the most number of votes wins the heat, and we move on to the next challenge. The loser of the heat is out of the competition: while they don't use a system of trap doors and alligator-laden moats in college basketball, we can use such things here.

This is the THIRD year for Pony Madness; only G3 adult ponies that were released since the last Madness will be elligible to compete. I have typed their names (more than 50 ponies total!) on a slip of paper each, and placed them in an urn (read: a small plastic tub). I randomly draw two names out, and those two ponies will compete in that day's heat. Only 32 ponies will end up competing.

Eventually, we will vote our way to a winner! We'll work ourselves into a VOTING FRENZY, WE WILL.


VOTING:
This year I am going to try using the POLL option for Madness; previously everyone typed their vote in a response, but previously there was no available poll option, either. HOPEFULLY this can work. I will quickly assess whether it is working or not after the first couple of heats. So, to cast your vote for the pony of your choice in each heat, you need only click a button.

Stipulation: Only one vote per person per heat. And only ONE vote per household. Entire families are not allowed to place votes seperately. You'll have to come to a consesus if more than one person in your home wants to vote, as you can only place one vote for the group of you.

When you vote, if you would like to also respond to the post with your reaoning, you may! You may even post responses in an effort to SAWY THE VOTERS with reasoning! It's welcomed!


ONTO Heat 1:

Let's get things started with the first Heat. Randomly selected is THISTLE WHISTLE, the nuerotic, scented pegasus, and FAIRY DUST, the shimmery "crystal princess."


thistlewhistle.jpg


fairydust.jpg


(I don't own most of these newest releases, so stock photos will be used this time around, I'm sorry to say!)


And below is the system of brackets that will help us follow the compeition.

1.jpg


(You can view the past 2 completed Madness brackets here: 2004 competition; 2005 competition.)


Let the MADNESS begin!
 
Hurrah!

I do love Fairy Dust, but Thistle's color combo... yeah, Thistle wins. ;)
 
We've got a winner, hands down. Thistle Whistle is going to win the whole thing, kit and caboodle!!!

Coolest new pony, bar none! *whistles*

*runs from clouds*


*whistles again*

Rock on, Thistle!!!!

By the by, Spooshiekins, you dribble heartily in a court of excellence for doing this for us!!! By the by by the by, the only tricky thing I see with doing it poll-style is that you'll have to time it really carefully if you want the votes to no longer count after exactly 24 hours... until you come back and close it, there'll still be votes sneaking in. :)
 
*doesn't like blue* I like 'em both, but I like white better than I like blue, so... Besides, I actually have Fairy Dust... Thistle has eluded me... *mutters about evil pony*

ZOMG this is so awesum i love it wow it rox!!1!
 
Awww, man. Fairy Dust WOULD have to go up against a peg! *Blows raspberries*

Well, Thistle would have gotten my vote, except for the fact that I fell madly deeply in love with FD after her tinselectomy. She's gorgeous. So, yeah.

:blush:

-Kelli
 
Could someone help me figure out how to use to poll :oops: Anyway, I want Fairy Dust. Pretty name and stunning symbol, nice colors. Actually she is probally my favorite in a long time.
 
My girls love Thistle Whistle too much. I have to vote for her! :D

*M*
 
Any one have the stats on the last two competitions??? Those were great, but I can't remember who won.
 
I fell in love with Fairy Dust the moment I saw her. Thistle Whistle is pretty but she just doesn't compare in my eyes.
 
This si already starting off quite difficult! I love Thistle Whistle, but I also love Fairy Dust's symbol!
Hmmm...
 
..

I vote for Thistle Whistle (I just don't like fairy dusts colors-and I would think a mlp with such a magical name would be more unique)I'm disappointed with fairy dust.
 
Sorry, I don't like TW's color scheme, generic pegasus pose with no embelishments, and the can-of-air-freshener cheapo symbol. Lackluster.
Fairy Dust gets my vote, for all the things TW doesn't do for me :roll:
 
StillandSilent said:
Could someone help me figure out how to use to poll :oops: Anyway, I want Fairy Dust. Pretty name and stunning symbol, nice colors. Actually she is probally my favorite in a long time.
just click the circle next to your choice, and hit "submit". you should see the poll at the top of the thread.

kiwi tart - spoosh linked to the previous 2 tourneys' charts, so you can see the winner there.

i had to go with thistle. *digs up "i <3 thistle whistle" sig* how could i possibly resist a neurotic pegasus with a speech impediment, in such pretty colors to boot?
 
I agree with Dancing Butterflies.. I don't have either, but I'm a sucker for ponies w/butterflies so I vote for Fairy Dust.
 
Ack, right from the get go I have a hard time choosing. I love the pegs, and Thistle Whistle is pretty... but I'm a sucker for butterfly/dragonfly themed ponies. Throw in the white body and glittery goodness, and I couldn't not vote for Fairy Dust. :D
 
I love white ponies and I love down the leg symbols, so I'm going for Fairy Dust.

Woot for Pony Madness!
 
Thistle Whistle smells nice, and looks more original. Plus she has such a distinct personality in the new movies. I voted for her!

Fairy Dust seems, well, not as original... or at least she doesn't stand out.
 
Although I own Fairy Dust, my vote has gone to Thistle Whistle! A Butterfly Island pony will win with me nearly any day :) While I am crazy about white ponies with brightly colored hair, FD's just not bright enough. And that tinsel is taking forever to pull! So, a whistle for the Thistle!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top