Challenge pic: can you identify these MLPTP members?

Sherbet

Sherbet

Scoops' #1 Fan
Joined
Jun 7, 2005
Messages
2,390
I just got back from vacation, and there will be plenty more pics to come. This one was inspired by MLPTP members that I talk to the most, have traded with, or who are just "prominent". Can you identify the members based on the ponies? And there are a couple of "trick" ponies here - let's see how you do!

DSC03135.jpg
 
I spy with my little eyes

Kar Red Roses, CannibalCow, SkippetyDoo and you! (Sherbet)
 
Hmmm, I'm thinking Strawberry Fair, Cannibal Cow, could that be me in there, maybe?, Kar Red Roses, maybe SatinSlipper, Sherbet of course. That's all that I can think of at the moment.
 
ding ding ding! So far we do have Strawberry Fair, Cannibal Cow, Gingerbread, Kar Red Roses, Skippety Doo, and me (Sherbet), but no I don't have Satin Slipper in there. Or do I? Like I said, there's a trick in here somewhere. And some are not as obvious! Keep guessing. :)
 
josiekat, sugarberry (not sure how the username is spelled), me, gingerbread, skyflier i don't know, kar red roses, maybe wind whistler is wildwrangler , skippetydoo, you sherbet and seaflower i don't know.
 
Great job identifying Josiekat, CC! I think that was a tough one. Sugarberry was intended for Strawberry Fair, though there's also Sugarberries that she could work for. :) Keep guessing!

Oh and Seahorse - I meant to bring a seapony with me and forgot! You're still in the picture though... somehow... :)
 
I see lunar_scythe. She's the member with the Bluebelle army.

I think Wind Whistler is there because she's the TP mascot.
 
Great job! There's only one that hasn't been correctly guessed, and that's Seaflower. Again, some of them have multiple possibilities, but here's the intended targets for the ones that have been guessed:

Blue Belle = josiekat
Sugarberry = Strawberry Fair
Cherries Jubilee = Cannibal Cow
Gingerbread = Ginderbread
Skyflier = Skyflier (yes, Starflower's sister)
Red Roses = Kar Red Roses
Wind Whistler = EVERYONE at the TP :)
Skippity Doo = Skippety Doo (note the spelling hehe)
Sherbet = me, Sherbet
Seaflower = ?

Some of the answers were really interesting to read. I also had Gusty and Minty with me and forgot to get them in the picture. Minty would be for StevesMinty and Shlugh, and others I'm sure, and Gusty for several people including Gusty325, MariosGusty, GustyFox, UnicornGusty, etc.

edit to add: I think that Seaflower needs a bit of a clue... it's not this person's name, but she once took an amazing picture of her Seaflower that always makes me associate that pony with her.
 
i think the blue pone with the shells, is SoSoft Claire! :)
Still, no Gusty.... :(
 
You got it Marios! Great job!! :)
 
cannibalcow said:
SSCs fav pony is honeycombe :D

fun contest!!
Click to expand...

mmhmm I know, and if I had Honeycomb, I would have taken her with me. I almost took Surprise because she looks similar, lol... but Seaflower will always remind me of SSC. :)

CC - stay tuned, you and Kar Red Roses are in an awesome photo. I might post it tomorrow. :)
 
If Minty was there, I would have incorrectly guessed myself.
 
Marios_Gusty said:
i think the blue pone with the shells, is SoSoft Claire! :)
Still, no Gusty.... :(
Click to expand...

COOOL! Awww thanks, guys! That's awesome that you thought to put me in the picture, Sherbet, and awesome that you could guess it, Marios!

Yes, although Honeycomb is my favorite pony, Seaflower runs a close second, and in the past I've been known to make a big deal about her. Hehe.

This was an AWESOME idea for a post, I've got to try this sometime.

By the way, the Bluebelle made me think of josiekat too!

:911:
 
*sniffs* I feel left out! Um..not really, I just wish I could have got here for the guessing before all the ponies true identies were figured out. Will you do another group pic?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top