2018 Secret Santa Swap Wishlists

Discussion in 'The Wishing Well' started by Gingerbread, Nov 20, 2018.

  1. Gingerbread

    Gingerbread Festive FelizNavidad Pony Staff Member Moderator

    Jan 3, 2006
    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:
    Wishlists for the 2018 Secret Santa Holiday Swap go here :santa:
  2. Skybreeze

    Skybreeze BBE Pony

    Oct 18, 2017
    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:
    Hooray for Christmas swap!!!!

    My desired condition is fairly wide. I don’t care if a pony is MIB or not. I obviously prefer if I don’t need to clean up or anything but am more lax for say G1 ponies. I would prefer ponies with no marker/pen/highlighter markings, no pony cancer, no bald ponies, no body parts missing (flutter wings okay obviously), prefer they come from non-smoking homes. Just mainly I would like them in display condition. Or worst case, easy fix to display.

    I don’t have any allergies, thankfully. I dislike orange and mint flavoured chocolates. I love chocolate (milk & white preferably), gummy type candies are always a plus, I enjoy cookies this time of year. Basically I like everything except orange and mint flavoured chocolate.

    I am a pony nerd but also love all things Disney. Anything and everything Stitch is also my jam. I am a huge Harry Potter fan as well and I am SUPER into Fantastic Beasts Niffler baby things right now. I don’t know why I’m fixated on them right now but I am. So cute!! So I do love the POP! Figures of all the Fantastic Beasts creatures as well.

    Pony Wishlist
    - Bushwoolies***
    - Mommy Bouquet
    - Princess Sparkle
    - So Soft Gusty
    - So Soft Posey*
    - So Soft Wind Whistler***
    - So Soft Shady***
    - Wig Wam (with accessories would be stellar but not required)
    - Starshine***
    - 35th Anniversary Firefly (MIB preferably)
    - 35th Anniversary Moondancer (MIB preferably)
    - 35th Anniversary Glory (MIB preferably)
    - 35th Anniversary Twilight (MIB preferably)
    - accessories for Slugger & Salty
    - Dragon costume***

    - Glitter Pinkie Pie (Pinkie Pie’s Boutique line)
    - Pinkie Pie (Elements of Friendship single)
    - Fluttershy (Shine Brite line)
    - Fluttershy (Elements of Friendship single)
    - Fluttershy (Pony Mania)
    - Starlight Glimmer (Pearlized)
    - Derpy (Collector Series: Fan collection 2)
    - Sea Swirl (Pearlized)
    - Sapphire Joy (Pearlized)
    - Meadow Flower (Pearlized)
    - Diamond Rose
    - Honey Buzz
    - Twist-A-Loo
    - Applebloom
    - Scootaloo (normal)
    - Silver Spoon
    - Diamond Tiara
    - Holly Dash
    - Princess Sterling

    - All About: Starlight Glimmer
    - All About: Lyra
    - All About: Pinkie Pie (showing pose)
    - All About: Fluttershy (standing pose)
    - School of Friendship: Fluttershy (glitter symbols)
    - School of Friendship: Rainbow Dash (glitter symbols)
    - School of Friendship: Cherilee (glitter symbols)
    - Shining Friends: Pinkie Pie
    - Classic Series: Pinkie Pie
    - Classic Series: Fluttershy
    - Magic Salaon: Pinkie Pie
    - Princess Luna (New glitter fashion size)
    - Princess Celestia (New glitter fashion size)
    - Flash Feather (baby hippogryph) ***
    - Flutter Cloud (baby hippogryph) ***
    - Sandbar (pony student) ***
    - Silverstream (Hippogryph) ***
    - Haven Bay (Seapony) ***

    Here’s photos of ones that I’ve had questions about previously, just to make things easier on everyone. :)
    A0DA46A3-C485-4255-A09A-8B24FF65BE4B.jpeg 61574E52-E65B-40D2-9ED8-19F82065D82C.jpeg CDB58B1B-B550-477F-853C-534D57195545.jpeg DA545184-2A12-415E-BB11-98AF26055286.jpeg 54023477-D388-4BB3-A569-827EB185F605.jpeg F1E1B363-2EEB-41E9-96EB-0374B4EAB815.jpeg
    A44C2A6F-BF52-402D-B0F5-A432B2CC259B.jpeg D796E7DF-8F94-4111-AFEA-1BDB16C1B174.jpeg 3D1A5D47-84D0-4140-B89D-5B90652752FA.jpeg
    Last edited: Nov 25, 2018
    Gingerbread likes this.
  3. Uftaki

    Uftaki Dollar Store Baby Fakie

    Sep 24, 2012
    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:
    Burnaby, B.C.
    I looooove Christmas! :D Almost everything Christmas! XD I love snowflakes, snowmen, reindeer, Santa, Christmas carols, Christmas trees, ornaments... Pretty much anything Christmas-y. :3 I also love plain milk chocolate (though I don't like chocolate with nuts in them - no allergies, just a preference). I love Disney, particularly the Disney ducks (Donald, Ducktales, etc)! I also love and collect pins (Disney and Olympic pins mainly, but anything goes! ^__^ ). I love video games, with titles like Zelda, Mario, Final Fantasys 6 & 7 and Chrono Trigger/Cross being among my favourites. Back to the Future is a huge favourite of mine, as is One Piece (Zoro and Sanji are my favourite characters).

    For ponies, I'd like them to be in pretty good condition. No haircuts, or major body flaws/damage. Some small dirt/marks that can be cleaned up is fine (I give all my ponies a spa day when I get them, even if they're right out of the box!), but no highlighter/sharpie/smooze/pony cancer/etc., please. Non-smoking homes is appreciated (pets are fine!)

    Pony Wishlists:
    Please see the attached pictures for my pony wishlists, sorted by generation. I collect G1, G3 and G4 brushables. Some of these ponies I don't know what the current prices for them are, so if any of the ponies listed here are above the spending limit, please ignore their inclusion on these lists. ^_^;;;

    Xmas G1 wishlist.png Xmas G3 wishlist.png Xmas G4 wishlist.png
    Skybreeze likes this.
  4. icecreamgirl

    icecreamgirl Dollar Store Baby Fakie

    Aug 16, 2014
    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:
    Pony wish list:

    G1 Ponies:
    So soft Truly
    So soft Taffy
    So so Skippety Doo
    TWE Whizzer
    TWE Sweet Pop
    TWE Gingerbread
    TAF Love Melody
    Sweet Lily
    Blueberry Baskets
    Confetti (US version)

    35th Anniversary ponies ~ Cotton Candy,, Glory, Twilight or Moondancer


    Acceptable Flaws:
    I don't mind some imperfections as long as the symbol and eyes are good, small rubs are ok. Small hair trims and marks to bottom of feet are ok too

    Unacceptable Flaws:
    I prefer ponies without cancer, major pen marks and major hair cuts. I'm not keen on regrind but a couple of small spots are acceptable.

    Extra info:
    My favourite colours are pink and blue. For christmas I like the classic christmas colours such as red, gold, green. I also like the blue/ silver combo!

    My favourite scents are fall and winter scents such as cinnamon, spice, cranberry. I like liquid soaps, shower gels, body lotion

    I like any MLP G1 merchandise including the retro stuff

    I am also a big fan of Peanuts ~ Snoopy in particular. I also love disney things. Favourite characters are Winnie the Pooh, Mickey and Minnie, Aristocats, Alice in Wonderland. I like stickers, stationary items such as pens, pencils, notepads, post its or fridge magnets. I love lip balms and I like homemade items and art. Socks would be good also, I like character/ Christmas ones, fuzzy or normal kind

    Favourite animals: cats, owls and rabbits.

    I love Christmas!!!
    I like cutie christmas things like snowmen, snowflakes, penguins, reindeer and santa! I also like the grinch. I love Christmas tree ornaments, we are having 2 trees in the house this year!
    I have a 6 year old son so anything fun would be great

    I like milk chocolate and gummy sweets and laffy taffy. I don't like coconut, marzipan, Turkish delight or liquorice. I also like savoury snacks especially cheese crunchy Cheetos

    I like drinking coffee and hot cocoa especially topped with marshmallows! I don't drink tea!

    I don't have any allergies
    Skybreeze likes this.
  5. Gingerbread

    Gingerbread Festive FelizNavidad Pony Staff Member Moderator

    Jan 3, 2006
    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:


    I'm not too picky, no major hair cuts, or really bad marks, no chewed on or missing limbs LOL! But little flaws or marks and such don't bother me. I know I've got some pricier ponies on my list, it's just the natural way since I'm close to finishing the US collection but I am totally happy with accessories!

    I like cooking/baking and decorating for the holidays. I decorate every room in the house. I'm not very religious so my decorations are more like Santa, reindeer, snowmen... I love Snoopy/Peanuts, Eeyore, Garfield and I also collect Charming Tails. I have a piebald dachshund, Frank who is my fur-baby :) so I tend to collect dachshund stuff too. I also collect gnomes and I like mice but not Mickey, nothing against good 'ol Mickey but I just like cute mice stuff. I like fun socks and jewelry, particularly earrings. If you're a good cook I also love to get people's tried and true recipes!

    None! I am trying to diet though, so little or no treats is ok with me. If you find you can't resist, I like chocolate, peanut butter and toffee. If you're international, I do love trying new things from different countries.
  6. Cactusflower

    Cactusflower Pied Piper of Ponies

    Jan 20, 2018
    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:
    The Great White North
    I'm super easy to buy for because there are so many choices. I'm also easily excited and easy to please. I'm missing a ton of G1's. I love G1 merchandise and stickers. Not a super picky collector, but no cancer, regrind, highlighter, smooze, or marker please. Marks on hooves are ok or small marks that aren't super noticeable or make come off. Not keen on major hair cuts or missing plugs, but for harder to find ponies, this is fine, because I will put in the time to restore. I love Christmas, but as I'm trying to downsize, I prefer consumable Christmas treats to decorations. I'm not crazy into sweets, but I love Waterbridge Wine Gums, Red Licorice and good quality dark chocolate. I wouldn't say no to any pony, 80's or Monster High tree decorations. I absolutely love handmade things.

    G1 Ponies still needed
    Year 1

    1. FF Blossom
    2. FF Snuzzle

    Year 2
    3. CF Blue Belle

    Year 3
    4. Long hair Bowtie
    5. Trickles Rainbow pony
    6. Seabreeze and shell
    7. High Tide and shell
    White Cap’s shell
    8. Wave Jumper and shell
    9. Sea Mist and shell
    Sand Dollar’s shell
    11.Sea Star
    12.Sea Shimmer

    Year 4
    13.BBE Baby Shady
    14.BBE Baby Tiddywinks
    15.BBE Baby Cuddles
    16.Snowball puppy
    17.Celebrate from party pack
    18.All 6 McDonald’s Collector charms

    Year 5
    19.Friendly (blue) bushwoolie
    20.Cheery (pink) Bushwoolie
    21.Wavy and float
    22.Surfy and float
    23.Sea spray and float
    24.Dipper and Float
    25.Sea breeze and float
    26.Salty and float
    27.SS Crumpet
    28.SS Bangles
    29.Newborn twin Rattles
    30.Pillow Talk
    31.Pink Dreams
    32.Night Cap
    33.Sleepy head
    35.Sweet Dreams
    36.TAF Sweet Tooth

    Year 6
    37.Coco Berry
    38.All mommy charms
    39.TAF Munchy
    40.BNG Twisty tail
    41.Princess Sunbeam
    42.Princess Mist
    43.Princess Taffeta
    44.Princess moondust
    45.Princess Dawn
    46.Newborn twins speckles,
    49.HT Squeezer
    52.Tall Tales
    53.Baby Graffiti
    54.MM Cloud Dreamer
    56.Watercolour sea ponies Foamy and float
    57.Misty and float
    58.Sealight and float
    59.Wave Dancers and float
    60.SW Lady Flutter
    62.SweetBerry Boysenberry Pie
    63.Raspberry Jam
    64.Cranberry Muffins
    66.Cha Cha
    67.Cat nip (white cat)

    Year 7

    68.MGR Tassles
    69.Diamond Dreams
    70.CC Caramel Crunch
    72.Lemon Treats
    73.Sunshine Mainsail
    74.Beach Ball
    75.Sea Flower
    76.TAF Megan
    77.Fancy pants Baby Bows
    78.Baby Starburst
    79.Dance and prance Twirler
    82.Tap Dancer
    84.Mom Bright Bouquet
    85.Baby Bright Bouquet
    86.Daddy Sweet Celebrations
    87.WW Whirly
    88.Cool Breeze
    90.Moon Jumper
    91.Starry Wings
    92.Playtime brothers Leaper
    94.Sparkle pony Twinkler
    95.Baby Stripes
    96.Baby Nectar
    97.Baby Lucky Leaf
    98.Baby Leafy
    99.Baby Pockets
    100. Baby Hoppy
    101. SHS Flowerburst
    102. Frilly Flower

    Year 8
    103. Drink and wet Snookums
    104. Cuddles
    105. SHS Sweet Sundrop
    106. Cha cha
    107. Daisy Dancer
    108. Twinkler

    Year 9
    109. Flower Dream
    110. Garden glow
    111. Precious pocket Sweet pocket
    112. Half Note Rockin Beat
    113. Baby Brightbow
    114. Baby Sunribbon
    115. Baby Toe Dancer
    116. Secret Surprise Secret Star
    117. Secret Beauty
    118. Pretty Puff
    119. Teeny Tiny Little tabby
    120. Little Whiskers
    121. Pink Princess pony

    Year 10
    122. Colourswirl Lovebeam
    123. Springy
    124. Starswirl
    125.Paradise baby Beach ball
    127. Sundazzle Sunbeam
    128. Sunsplasher
    129. Sunglory
    130. Teeny Tiny Rattles
    131. Tattles
    132. Bootsie
    133. Tootsie
    134. Sniffles
    135 .Snookums
    136. Purple sweet talkin
    137. Lovin’ kisses
    138. Flower Fantasy sweet blossom
    139. Flowerbelle
    140. Fancy mermaid pearly
    141. Sea princess
    142. Sea Shimmer

    143. Baby sugarcake
    144. Baby game time
    145. Baby blue ribbon
    146. Baby love melody
    147. Baby Dancing Butterflies
    148. Baby Milky Way
    149. Baby Sweet Tooth
    150. Baby Sugarberry
    151. Baby Up, Up, and Away
    152. Violet FEB
    153. Daffodil MARCH
    154. Daisy APRIL
    155. Rose JUNE
    156. Morning Glory SEPT
    157. Chrysanthemum NOV
    158. L’il Tot
    159. Mommy pony
    160. Baby pony
    161. Scribbles
    162. Dabble
    163. Rapunzel
    164. Rama Llama
    165. Magenta Satin and Lace
    166. Twinkler (MO)
    167. Napper (MO)
    168. Sweet Scoops
    169. Purple Valentine Twin

    Any G1 accessories, stickers or combs.

    Pony wear
    Sweet Dreams
    Parade Pizzaz
    The Tea Party
    Pony Luv
    Lights Camera Action
    Something Old, Something New
    Pony Work out
    Having a Luau
    Strike up the Band
    Neon Lights
    Hit the Slopes (skiis only)
    Milk and Cookies
    Sidewalk Surfer
    Pretty as a picture
    Pony Holiday
    Galaxy Glamour
    Academy Award
    In the Center ring

    International Ponies needed
    Activity Club Baby Ponies
    Baby Ponies (First Edition)
    Any UK baby pony
    Tutti Frutti
    Any Dragon that came with Princess ponies
    Ice Crystal
    Non so soft Wind Whistler, Gusty, Shady, Magic Star
    Sea Ponies
    Surf Dancer with Shell
    Wave Breaker with Shell
    Sea Spray with Shell
    Playschool Baby Ponies
    Schooltime Ponies
    Starlight Baby Ponies (except Baby Mischief)
    Cookery Ponies
    Good Weather
    Romance Ponies Love Letter

    35th Anniversary Firefly (MIB preferably)
    - 35th Anniversary Moondancer (MIB preferably)
    - 35th Anniversary Glory (MIB preferably)
    - 35th Anniversary Twilight (MIB preferably)

    I also love Monster High and I don’t have any version of the dolls listed below yet. I prefer dolls with clothes, and shoes at least.

    Abbey Bominable
    Alivia Stein
    Amanita Nighshade
    Avea Trotter
    Batsy Claro
    CA Cupid
    Clawdeen Wolf
    Clawdia Wolf
    Ebbie Blue
    Ghoulia Yelps
    Kelpie Blue
    Lorna McNessie
    Pawla Wolf
    Wydowna Spider

    Any Manster
    Last edited: Nov 25, 2018
  7. Cactusflower

    Cactusflower Pied Piper of Ponies

    Jan 20, 2018
    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:
    The Great White North

    You have Galaxy and SS Lickity Split coming to you in a couple weeks ;)
    Skybreeze likes this.
  8. Skybreeze

    Skybreeze BBE Pony

    Oct 18, 2017
    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:
    :p:oops: I just copied my list from the Halloween swap and didn’t even think to look at my G1 list. Thanks for keeping an eye out for me. :xmashug:

    @Uftaki - where do you itemize your want lists like that? It’s so fancy-dancy.
    Last edited: Nov 25, 2018
  9. Uftaki

    Uftaki Dollar Store Baby Fakie

    Sep 24, 2012
    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:
    Burnaby, B.C.
    @Skybreeze - Thank you! :D I make them myself, in MS Paint. It's a bit of a ... Well, VERY laborious process to get those lists all set up, but I love having picture checklists to keep track of what I have and what I need. :3

    How I made them is I get the pictures of the ponies + info (year, group, etc) from other sites. Then I make a blank grid in MS paint, and type in all the information onto that grid. Pictures are re-sized in Gimp (another picture-editing program) and popped into the grid at the same time. Photoshop or Gimp may be "easier" with their layers, etc. But I'm not the best at using those, and I like the simplicity of working with MS Paint. ^_^; I have a bunch of files, now, for each generation I collect (both blank and checked versions).
    Cactusflower likes this.
  10. Cactusflower

    Cactusflower Pied Piper of Ponies

    Jan 20, 2018
    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:
    The Great White North
    @Uftaki - your lists are amazing. I love to have checklists with pictures. You have saved me time when checking to see if I have certain ponies and especially with the G3's because you arranged them by colour, which is super helpful. While we are on the subject, your G1 list has decreased to one a few ponies. Are you almost complete for G1's?

    I'm completely neurotic about checklists. I have a million different types of checklists. I like the one I posted above, because I know I still need
    Skybreeze likes this.
  11. Uftaki

    Uftaki Dollar Store Baby Fakie

    Sep 24, 2012
    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:
    Burnaby, B.C.
    @Cactusflower - thank you. ^_^ I love having them, too. Glad to have helped you with them! My G1 list here on the Secret Santa is actually a shortened list, of ponies I think are a little cheaper and/or possibly easier for people to actually find. The others I still need would be very hard to find, and/or too expensive. ^_^; (I still need about 60+ to complete my G1s).
    Skybreeze likes this.
  12. maycrestmom

    maycrestmom Bushwoolie

    Mar 22, 2010
    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:
    My G1 list is really short, sorry, but I am fine if you find a baity pony and make him/her a custom for the season :)

    I would be thrilled to have any of the fancy pants babies :) except for the green one - sunnybunches :) I just got her to go along as another blossom baby :) since I love making pony families.
    also G1 is that baby boy with the dragon
    brush n grow bouquet -the white one, and the yellow one - pretty vision
    sundae best coco - but this one I am picky that she is really really amazing blue still, not faded

    I think these qualify as G1 = an HQG1C - those green boys are fab to me = oh and love those santa hats :)
    and now that the CP have returned :) a 35th anniversary of minty

    pony wear I am looking for party dresses - have the red hearts one and pink-sunday stroll one but that is it
    always on the look out for ribbons and barrettes -don't have to be G1 just in that style for dressing up a MLP :)

    for G3 looking for a loose but fab condition lily lightly

    for G4 hmm... a sorin' and a big mac would top my list

    than for similar to / in the catagory of :

    a squishy minty - think that they are playskool? And I don't have a minty christmas ornament
    a funko I think - loyal figures of a glow minty
    (if ya haven't figured out minty is my army pony and my favorite color is green)
    Any of the G4 - they called mini figs? blind bag size = love boys and any of the non-main friends

    in the minty G3 spirit any fun cozy socks - I am always wearing socks in the house so love comfy socks :) bonus attached to a blind bag minty :)

    all things homemade fudge, home made cookies/bars etc. heck even rice krispie treats
    I love chai tea, matcha tea and any good christmas spice seasonal tea and hot chocolate packs
    and yes :) love mint candies (if ya wanted a theme) tis the season for candy canes :)

    love stickers to put on my packages
    can never have enough chapstick
    I love all things kawaii ( also collect tokidoki) so all things rainbows even when it is snowing :)

    I'll see if I can add a bit more - point is I hope this gets ya some ideas and most of all ya have fun 'cause really it is just the taking time out during this season to have fun and follow the joy :)
  13. MLPMommy4Life

    MLPMommy4Life Fraser, your wolf just ate my jelly doughnut!

    Feb 5, 2012
    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:
    Sunny South Florida, West Palm Beach

    Acceptable flaws:
    Hair trims
    Marks on the bottoms of hooves
    Fading (slight)
    I'm not really too picky... as long as she displays nicely, I'm good.

    Unacceptable flaws:
    Marks on the body
    Missing body parts
    Hard body (Plasticizer loss)

    G1 and G3 are okay not to be MIB. G4 MIB is preferred, but not mandatory.

    If I see G1 merchandise in the store, it comes home with me...lol.... ;-)

    Extra Information:

    I love to work on the computer, take photos, draw and write stories
    I have 3 cats and a small dog (chihuahua) - They all love cat treats, even the dog LOL
    My favorite colors are orange and blue
    Favorite animals: Cats, dogs, horses, owls and cardinals
    I love reusable items - containers, especially
    I love trinkets, and collect Ladybugs/Lovebugs and Maneki Neko (Lucky) Cats
    I *LOVE* Mountain Dew and crunchy regular cheetos

    Other fandom loves:
    Doctor Who
    Guardians of the Galaxy and Jurassic World (more specifically Chris Pratt)
    Mickey Mouse
    Fast and Furious (Especially Brian O'Conner/Paul Walker)

    Scents I like:

    Pearson's Salted Nut Rolls
    Chocolate / peanut butter cups
    Chocolate covered cherries
    Candy canes, especially the soft kind
    Corn Chips
    Hot Chocolate, especially peppermint flavored!
    I got into Kinder Joys this year... the tiny toys go on my computer at my new job, and I love the frosting and wafers on the other side of the egg.

    Holiday Likes:
    I love all things Christmas. Can't really go wrong with Christmas for me. I especially love angels.

    Not big on perfume
    Vanilla scent
    Sticky candy (Like taffy...I try to stay away from it because of my dental work)
    Tea of any kind


    Thanks to doing some pony-related work for MustBeJewel, I'm starting a Derpy army. Anything you can find to add outside of the Wal-Mart stuffed toy, the small brushable and the Stuff Happens sticker is very welcomed by me!!!!
    Anything you can find with Discord is also welcomed by me... I just LOVE him.
    Paradise is my favorite G1 pony

    I think that's it... :)

Share This Page