Wishing Well Question: Different WW for Non-MLP?

[Minty317]

Hello everyone,

I don't know if this has ever already been addressed, but do you guys think there should be a seperate Wishing Well for our wishlists of non-MLP items?

Because it specifically states on here that the the Wishing Well is only for MLP items, yet many people would trade non-MLP items for MLP (I've noticed members that still mention other items that they would trade for, but those are not all-inclusive lists usually).

Many members have extensive pony wishlists but not for what they would like for other things. I know there is the "Want to Buy" forum, but that seems like it's one item at a time, not a list that stays up and gets continuously updated.

It seems like a good idea to me, but I'm new so I don't really know how everything works around here yet and I don't want to overstep my boundaries by suggesting things that don't apply, so I was wondering what others' oppinions were. Perhaps it would be too "non-MLP" for this site, or maybe the "Want to Buy" is good enough...not sure.

What do you think?? :?:

 

[thebeth]

meh... as far as I'm concerned, I think the Wishing Well is for people who want ponies but don't feel like paying for them at the moment and others can show an act of kindness by sending them something on their wishlist.
Not always the case, but it's what I think.
And I guess the want to buy forums are enough. If people feel like putting a whole list of things on there, they could.

 

[Pikabubba]

I think this is a great question (one of the mods may move this question to another forum for you).
You can always click ont he announcements forum. There's a suggestion box topic somewhere near the top and you can put your suggestion in. It may or may not happen, but you can at least try?
I know a ton of people here may like that idea as they collect many things other than MLP and would like to have a place to list their wants to keep track of what they need. I know I use this WW for my wants and update mine all the time. Beats writing on paper. Otherwise I'd have scratch off marks and add ins all over the place

 

[Minty317]

I think this is a great question (one of the mods may move this question to another forum for you).
You can always click ont he announcements forum. There's a suggestion box topic somewhere near the top and you can put your suggestion in. It may or may not happen, but you can at least try?
I know a ton of people here may like that idea as they collect many things other than MLP and would like to have a place to list their wants to keep track of what they need. I know I use this WW for my wants and update mine all the time. Beats writing on paper. Otherwise I'd have scratch off marks and add ins all over the place

Thanks Pika, yeah sometimes I'm not sure exactly which forum to put a question in. And thanks for letting me know about the suggestion box too. I'll give it a try!

:yippie:

 

[Anuba]

I think that is a great question. I know that with the misc. things I've seen posted here to be sold that I would make a separate wishlist for non MLP things. I am into anime and things from the old cartoon shows that I used to watch. I think that it would be great to have another place to put non pony wishlists.