I had to go with Tropical Surprise. I like her colors (green!) and it bothers me that a pony named Thisle Wistle smells like coconuts! WHAT ! She shoud have been flower scented or something. Or had a different name that fit the coconut scent.
Tropical Surprise gets my vote - I could never understand why Thistle Whistle smelt like Coconut, and Tropical Surprise's symbol makes more sense for her character
I voted for Thistle Whistle:
1) I like the coconut smell more than the so-called "flower" smell
2) She's a pegasus
3) She was a major character in a couple MLP DVDs, with a strong distinct personality.
Go Thistle Whistle!
btw, I was out of town for over a week and missed SO much of this March Madness, didn't get to vote for over a week. The only computer I was able to access (in a school library) had internet settings which blocked me out of this forum. :? But I'm back!