Pony pick

Tak

A long time ago…
MLPTP Supporter
Joined
Dec 26, 2015
Messages
10,483
If you had to sell all except for one set of ponies (e.g. all the g1 te, all the g4.5 merponies, all the slh g3's, etc) which would you keep? I'm just curious as to which are most popular, or not, or if maybe you would pick only one character?
 
I would keep the big brother ponies. Most ponies I like are subject to colors and symbols, whether I like them or not, but I love the shape of the big brother ponies, and I'm more familiar with them than I am the mountain boys, though I'd gladly keep those ones instead.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak
This is tough. I think I would keep the G1 princesses, though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak
My G1 fire fly and baby firefly and princess Tiffany my dad bought them on trips and gave them to me when he got home. I'd keep my big sea pony rarity G4.5 cause she pretty
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak
Gah! Too many to choose and you all 3 have great picks!
 
I can't find myself to sale my collection
I love it so much my family wants me
To sale my collection because
They think I'm crazy and I have some rare
One's but if it comes to it I would keep my twilight sparkle ARMY

I never wanted to sell mine and I don't care what anyone except my daughter says, but sometimes life demands sacrifice for something you want or need. I'm trying to decide which ponies I absolutely can't let go of. Aside from my purple ponies, it looks like the g1 babies and te have won.
 
I would keep my surprise army. I love my collection and it would be very hard for me to part with it. :/
 
I think I'd keep my original g1 ponies that i got from my Aunty and Mum, they're not a particular set but I'm way to attached to them to ever even contemplate parting with them! Other than those, I'd keep my TE ponies and my seapony army!

Oh and also my g3 Kimono. She was the first pony I ever received, way back in 2003. I got her before I even got my g1s :')
 
Most customs aren't worth too much, anyway. Reselling them would just be as loss monetarily as well as emotionally, since most are personal. I'm not saying that none resell for a decent price. More just the special orders.
 
I want to reply to this but I am having trouble. My mind is stuck with all my favorite ponies. It seems I have a favorite from each group, I am not fond of all ponies in one group except two. Rockin Beat and Tropical Ponies. To lose my Mainsail would make me so sad, yet I only like 3 of the ponies in that group where I love all the others. I can't answer this question truthfully. I can only answer the question of what favorite ponies would you keep if you could say only have 10 ponies lol. When it comes to groups...its just too hard. I tried. The closest I could come to a group of ponies answer would be the Sunshine ponies even though I am really not fond of Beach Ball. I love Mainsail so much I would probably have to save her and that is her group. Sigh....that would be a sad day cause I have sooooo many favorites lol. Then there is the issue of Cat Pee Pony. I owe her a decent life. After all she was seriously abused and disrespected all her life. I have tried to help her and even got her counseling. The damage is still there and I can't just leave her behind...even though she kinda smells like one.:D:rolleyes:
 
I think it also would be hard for me to part with my mail orders and nirvana they are so hard to track down.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tak
Yea I am so in love with my Dutch Ponies. I need to get another one of those My Little Pony barn cases. I like to put my favorites in those cases under my bed rather than in the mountain of ponies in my pony cabinet. LOL I have a few that need to be in a case. I have three cases of favorite ponies right now. I think I need two more of those cases and that will be perfect to house my favorite ponies out of the 400 I have in the G1 category.
 
I don't own an entire set of anything yet but I'd definitely keep my male ponies. I've always completely loved the male ponies ever since I was little and first started collecting, and I can't imagine parting with them *protectively hugs my Steamer, one of the first G1 ponies I ever got*. Plus I have a goal to collect all the male ponies one day (except for any OOAK ones, of course).

I know it says one set but I'd also keep my very first pony, G3 Strawberry Swirl. She's been through a lot haha, I even took her to Disney World when they had that Build-A-Pony thing and dressed her up. Fun times ^u^
 
My nieces gave me a late valentine gift well there mom and dad too but it was sweet. Its a bucket with a tiny tiny princess twilight and some candy. The bucket is just perfect for my pain brushes.
My bro-in law while not a pony got me a Wonder Woman sword that make noses for my birthday LOL we buy each other toy on holidays. I am also the only one who know what he is talking about in Zelda.
 
Not sure of every 5 below but after going to my doctor then my eye app my mom took me to get some stuff for Easter. The had the Guardian of Harmony Chrissy vs Spike for 5.00 and the G4 Tinker toys Fluttershy, AppleJack, and Rarity for 5.00.
Needless to say I got a Rarity Tinker toy. I might if I can find the money go get the other two they look interesting. I have Chrissy vs spike already.
 
I don't have sets (yet!), but I love all my G1 unicorns, since they're my favorite out of all 3 pony species. It would be that and a hard toss up between them and the loads of money I've spent on Build-A-Bear ponies and outfits, and Medley. I think in the end, if forced to keep only one, I'd keep Medley. She survived the great pony purge of 2007 and has been in my life since I was three. No way I'd be throwing away a decades old relationship like that! Speaking of, since I can't get rid of her smooze, I really owe her a new tail ribbon. :sadpony: :oops: (Once upon a time, I told myself once she was all cleaned up, I'd get her a new one, but that's impossible because the smooze is too engrained.)
 
I am more fond of the custom I make and the still the one that my family and friends have given me. but my darn G3.5 babies are growning on me
 
I have some special ponies that sit next to my bed that I couldn't get rid of, when I'm sitting in my room I can hear them say thing to me, some nice things and then some things that are sinister, so I can't get rid of them because I have to protect other people from their evil influences.
 
Back
Top