MLPTP's 2018 Halloween Swap Wishlists

Discussion in 'The Wishing Well' started by Gingerbread, Sep 15, 2018.

  1. Gingerbread

    Gingerbread Festive FelizNavidad Pony Staff Member Moderator

    Jan 3, 2006
    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:
    Post your wishlists here for the 2018 Halloween swap :crystalball:
  2. Ology

    Ology Gunters Life!

    Oct 6, 2013
    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:
    Edge of Reality and to the Left!
    I love every thing about Halloween don't mind Gore just no spider or bugs.
    MY likes are
    Halloween decoration
    Cling for window
    Cats black
    Lights purple
    Pumpkin not glittery
    Spooky dolls
    Five Nights At Freddy’
    Stanley, from Twisted Ones

    Circus Baby'
    Likes: I like





    FAVORITE color purple, black, silver, fall colors.

    Paranormal stuff

    Old Dolls

    Raggedy Ann dolls

    Old monster movies


    Favorite movies are : Shape of Water , Labyrinth and Last Unicorn.

    dream catchers

    I love Halloween and Christmas

    Mummies and Egyptian things


    Beauty and the beast

    MOnster High Cleo only




    Socks fuzzy or soft
    favorite candy is cherry suckers and reesies piece and chocolate

    allergies: Latex Banana, Apples. scented lotion except honey suckle and cherry and nuts in candy

    I don't like

    the color yellow

    Tinkerbell anything

    bright colors beside Purple shades



    I am a G4 and G4.5 collector I am ok with out of the box but please not smoking homes and no hilighter marks.
    Fashion Style Snap on fashion Rainbow Dash
    Land to sea fashion Fluttershy



    Equestria Girls Legend of Everfree Crystal Gala Rarity
    My Little Pony Equestria Girls Rarity Relaxing Beach Lounge Doll Playset


    Rarity G4
    FS Radiance
    Sea pony Rarity large and Med plushy
    Rarity in plastic purse
    Rarity Carousal bouquet from movie
    Rarity Carousal Bouquet Original.
    Rarity puggle clip

    Last edited: Sep 24, 2018
    Skybreeze likes this.
  3. Skybreeze

    Skybreeze BBE Pony

    Oct 18, 2017
    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:
    So, I have thought long and hard about this wish list. I wanted to put together something with things that are easier to find. Maybe with a few not so easy finds. But in all things I’d love to see in a fun Halloween package. :Glowpump:

    My desired condition is fairly wide. I don’t care if a pony is MIB or not. I obviously prefer if I don’t need to clean up or anything but am more lax for say G1 ponies. I would prefer ponies with no marker/pen/highlighter markings, no pony cancer, no bald ponies, no body parts missing (flutter wings okay obviously), prefer they come from non-smoking homes. Just mainly I would like them in display condition. Or worst case, easy fix to display.

    I don’t have any allergies, thankfully. I dislike candy corn and marshmallow-y type treats. Oh! Tootsie rolls, hate them. I love Laffy Taffy, chocolates and gummy type candies.

    I am a pony nerd but also love all things Disney. Anything and everything Stitch is also my jam. I am also well versed in everything Harry Potter. I have a small collection of HP books from all over the world. I love to draw so naturally any stationary type stuff I love. Stickers are always fun. I love Studio Ghibli films and related merch. I am a big coffee and loose leaf tea drinker. Ummm, yeah... I think that’s a wide array of ideas?

    During Halloween, I love to binge watch a lot of horror movies. But then I will watch Hocus Pocus at least weekly as it is my all time favourite holiday movie. Hands down the best movie. I also like the Halloween Town movies as cheesy as they are. Lol

    Anyways, here is my wishlist. Be forewarned it is long. I figured it gives a lot of options.

    Pony Wishlist
    - Bushwoolies
    - Mommy Bouquet
    - Moondancer
    - Princess Sparkle
    - So Soft Gusty
    - So Soft Lickety Split
    - So Soft Posey
    - So Soft Wind Whistler
    - Starshine
    - Twinkle Eyed Galaxy
    - 35th Anniversary Firefly (MIB preferably)
    - 35th Anniversary Moondancer (MIB preferably)
    - 35th Anniversary Glory (MIB preferably)
    - 35th Anniversary Twilight (MIB preferably)

    - Glitter Pinkie Pie (Pinkie Pie’s Boutique line)
    - Pinkie Pie (Elements of Friendship single)

    - Fluttershy (Shine Brite line)
    - Fluttershy (Elements of Friendship single)
    - Fluttershy (Pony Mania)
    - Starlight Glimmer (Pearlized)
    - Derpy (Collector Series: Fan collection 2)
    - Sea Swirl (Pearlized)
    - Sapphire Joy (Pearlized)
    - Meadow Flower (Pearlized)
    - Diamond Rose
    - Honey Buzz
    - Twist-A-Loo
    - Applebloom
    - Scootaloo (normal)
    - Silver Spoon
    - Diamond Tiara
    - Holly Dash
    - Princess Sterling


    - All About: Starlight Glimmer
    - All About: Lyra
    - All About: Pinkie Pie (showing pose)
    - All About: Fluttershy (standing pose)
    - All About: Cherilee
    - Shining Friends: Pinkie Pie
    - Shining Friends: Fluttershy
    - Flash Feather (baby hippogryph) ***
    - Flutter Cloud (baby hippogryph) ***
    - Sandbar (pony student) ***
    - Silverstream (Hippogryph) ***
    - Haven Bay (Seapony) ***
    - Friendship Festival: Princess Parade
    - Spitfire
    - Maud Pie
    - Big Macintosh
    - Derpy
    - Coco Pommel
    Last edited: Sep 17, 2018
    Ology likes this.
  4. Gingerbread

    Gingerbread Festive FelizNavidad Pony Staff Member Moderator

    Jan 3, 2006
    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:

    I'm not too picky, no major hair cuts, or really bad marks, no chewed on or missing limbs LOL! But little flaws or marks and such don't bother me. I know I've got some pricier ponies on my list, it's just the natural way since I'm close to finishing the US collection but I am totally happy with accessories!

    I like cooking/baking and decorating for the holidays. I love Snoopy/Peanuts, Eeyore, Garfield and I also collect Charming Tails. I have a dachshund, Frank who is my fur-baby :) so I tend to collect dachshund stuff too. I also like mice but not Mickey, nothing against good 'ol Mickey but I just like cute mice stuff. I like fun socks and jewelry, particularly earrings.
    As far as Halloween stuff goes I like cute Halloween themed stuff, I'm not really into the gross/gory stuff. I like it all, bats, pumpkins, witches, ghosts...I get into all the holidays and love this time of year!

    None! I am trying to diet though, so little or no treats is ok with me. If you find you can't resist, I like chocolate, peanut butter and toffee and since it's that time of year, of course pumpkin too! If you're international, I do love trying new things from different countries.
    Ology and Skybreeze like this.
  5. Uftaki

    Uftaki Dollar Store Baby Fakie

    Sep 24, 2012
    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:
    Burnaby, B.C.
    Like Gingerbread, I'm getting close to finishing a couple of my collections, too... so some ponies on my wishlists here may be a bit over the price limit. (I took the average price listed on Blue Rose's page for the G1s, and I'm not up-to-date on G3 or G4 prices). If they are over the limit, please ignore them. ^_^;

    For flaws, I don't want any haircuts, or major marks (pen/highlighter/sharpie, etc), no smooze/mold/pony cancer if it can be avoided... or chewed or missing limbs. (lol) Minor flaws or spots/marks/dirt are okay, because I always give my ponies a spa day whenever they arrive at their new home. :)

    For non-pony likes, I love collecting Disney pins :) (almost any pin, really). I also like Ducktales and Darkwing Duck, One Piece, Final Fantasies 6 & 7, Chrono Trigger/Cross, Legend of Zelda, Back to the Future, the Neverending Story, and the Last Unicorn. Of slightly smaller interests are Tale Spin, Chip & Dale Rescue Rangers, Pokemon (love all the Eeveelutions, Vulpix, and Litten especially), Fullmetal Alchemist, Sailor Moon, Kingdom Hearts, and Mario (mostly Mario, Luigi and Toad, but the others are fine, too). I like cute little earrings, and comfy socks. I love plain and simple milk chocolate, and candies (no nuts/peanut butter/marshmallow/licorice). No food allergies, just a preference.

    For Halloween stuff, I'm not too big on gross/gory/scary stuff. I like Nightmare Before Christmas, Beetlejuice, Ghostbusters... light-hearted, fun and cute stuff like that. Witches, cats, bats, skeletons, ghosts, pumpkins + jack-o-lanterns are all good. No spiders or bugs tho, please.

    And the pony wishlists:
    G1 wishes.png G3 wishes.png G4 wishes.png

    ETA: Ignore/cancel the G4 "magical scenes" Fluttershy, Rainbow Dash & Rarity"
    Last edited: Sep 23, 2018
    Skybreeze likes this.
  6. kittensquid

    kittensquid Little Pretty Kitty

    Aug 5, 2011
    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:
    Wisconsin, USA
    G1 Wishlisht:
    • Baby Northstar (FT or Sparkle)
    • January Carnation
    • Baby Rainfeather
    • Baby Rainribbon
    • Baby Sweetstuff
    • Baby Doodles
    • Glittering Gem
    • SS Hippity Hop
    • Locket
    • Stardancer (store or MO)
    • Baby Sticky
    • Twilight
    • Teeny Tiny Sniffles
    • Teeny Tiny Snookums
    (I used the Bluerose price guide on these, so if they're currently out of price range, please do let me know.)

    G4.5 Wishlist:
    • Cutie Mark Crew Blindboxes (I'll even provide the numbers on the bottoms of the ones I have so hopefully no duplicates if my partner wants to go that route)
    Flaws I'm Cool With: Slight haircuts, marks on bottoms of hooves, small marks on legs, regrind, mild smells (e.g. perfume)

    Flaws I'm Not Cool With: Severe haircuts, cancer, big old marks/ scratches/ bite marks, really bad smells, severe eye/ symbol rub

    What you should know about me: I have type 2 diabetes, so sugar free candy only please. I love chocolate, toffee, marshmallow, and peanut butter. Do not like grape or coffee flavors. If sugar free candy is hard to find, you can always send my cat some cat treats, she's not picky at all.

    What I love about Halloween: black cats!!!!!, witches, ghosts, skeletons (I'm a sucker for skeleton memes and jokes), bats, owls, graveyards, spooky and/or spoopy things. I love jewelry and decorations, and socks too. Not too much I really don't like, maybe don't send a bunch of live centipedes though.

    Other fun stuff: I love cats and opossums!!!! Squids and octopi are also favorites of mine. I like Pokemon, Attack on Titan, Glitter Force, Hello Kitty and all the other Sanrio characters, Pusheen, Star Wars (especially Porgs), fun stuff for my dolls (Barbie, MH, Pullip, etc.), forest animals (raccoons, foxes, etc.), Legos/Playmobil, fun pens, and candles/incense (I like flower scents the best).
    Ology and Skybreeze like this.
  7. icecreamgirl

    icecreamgirl Dollar Store Baby Fakie

    Aug 16, 2014
    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:
    Here is my pony wish list :catpumpkin:

    G1 Ponies:
    So soft Truly
    So soft Taffy
    So so Skippety Doo
    So soft Sundance
    TWE Whizzer
    TWE Sweet Pop
    TWE Gingerbread
    TAF Love Melody
    Sweet Lily
    Blueberry Baskets
    Confetti (US version)

    35th Anniversary ponies ~ Cotton Candy, Snuzzle, Glory, Twilight or Moondancer


    Acceptable Flaws:
    I don't mind some imperfections as long as the symbol and eyes are good, small rubs are ok. Small hair trims and marks to bottom of feet are ok too

    Unacceptable Flaws:
    I prefer ponies without cancer, major pen marks and major hair cuts. I'm not keen on regrind but a couple of small spots are acceptable.

    I prefer the cutsie side of halloween - black cats, cute ghosts, pumpkins etc. I don't like gore and blood or zombies. I am a fan of Nightmare before Christmas especially Jack Skelletington

    My likes:
    I am a big fan of Peanuts ~ Snoopy in particular. I also love disney stuff, Disney Characters I particularly like are Winnie the Pooh and friends, Aristocats, Minnie and Mickey. Anything Disney Halloween related would be awesome
    I also like Pusheen

    I like stickers, stationary items such as pens, pencils, erasers, notepads, post its, washi tape or fridge magnets.

    Socks are good also - I have medium sized feet!

    I would be happy with some halloween decorations - I love decorating with my son for Halloween or something to put on or in the window would be cool. Halloween themed kitchen items would be welcome, such as cookie cutters, tea towel, cupcake decorations

    Favourite animals: cats, owls and rabbits. We have 2 cats ~ Sunny and Marshmallow

    My favourite scents are autumn and winter scents such as cinnamon, spice, cranberry. I also like fruity smells. I like liquid soaps, shower gels, body lotion

    Chocolate - I like milk and white chocolate. Chocolate with caramel, marshmallow, nuts all good! I don't like coconut, marzipan, Turkish delight, peanut butter

    Sweets - I like gummy sweets. I love laffy taffy. I don't like black liquorice

    Chips - I love Cheetos, cheese and the jalepeno and cheese flavour.

    Drinks - I like drinking coffee and hot cocoa especially topped with marshmallows! I don't drink tea!

    I don't have any allergies
    Last edited: Sep 21, 2018
    Skybreeze likes this.
  8. Cactusflower

    Cactusflower Pied Piper of Ponies

    Jan 20, 2018
    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:
    The Great White North
    Ok, I'm clearly the easiest, because my list is extensive. Halloween is my favourite time of year. I love costumes, dressing up and CANDY. Jack Skellington is super cool. I love spooky, creepy gory. It's all awesome. My favourite candy is Red or Black Licorice, Wine Gums. I have no allergies, unless you’re planning on sending me a tree or ragweed. Please no ragweed. I'm not a huge fan of chocolate and I don't like anything coffee, but I love Coffee Crisp chocolate bars, which makes no sense at all.

    I’m gonna post my whole G1 wishist. It’s long, but tons of options. I’m not super picky, but I would prefer ponies with no marker/pen/highlighter markings, no pony cancer, no bald ponies, no major haircuts, prefer they come from non-smoking homes. I have almost no accessories, so I'd love anything. Oh, and just recently became a fan of G1 pony clothes. I'm get excited very easily and I'm a super grateful person, so I'll love getting anything really.

    In addition to the ridiculous amount of pony options I also like many nerdy things:

    Emily the Strange

    Star Wars

    Star Trek

    Stranger Things

    Monster High Dolls (don’t have any, but love them)

    G1 Ponies still needed

    Year 1

    1. FF Blossom

    2. FF Cotton Candy

    3. FF Snuzzle

    Year 2

    4. CF Blue Belle

    5. Brandy the pup

    Sealight’s shell

    Year 3

    6. Curly hair Apple Jack

    7. Curly hair Bowtie

    8. Trickles Rainbow pony

    9. Seabreeze and shell

    10.High Tide and shell

    White Cap’s shell

    11.Wave Jumper and shell

    12.Sea Mist and shell

    Sand Dollar’s shell


    14.Sea Star

    15.Tiny Bubbles

    16.Sea Shimmer

    Year 4

    17.BBE Baby Shady

    18.BBE Baby Halfnote

    19.BBE Baby Tiddywinks

    20.BBE Baby Cuddles

    21.Snowball puppy

    22.Celebrate from party pack

    23.All 6 McDonald’s Collector charms

    Year 5

    24.Friendly (blue) bushwoolie

    25.Eager (dark pink)

    26.Cheery (pink)

    27.BB Slugger

    28.Wavy and float

    29.Surfy and float

    30.Sea spray and float

    31.Dipper and Float

    32.Sea breeze and float

    33.Salty and float

    34.SS Crumpet

    35.SS Bangles

    36.Newborn twin Rattles

    37.Pillow Talk

    38.Pink Dreams

    39.Night Cap

    40.Sleepy head


    42.Sweet Dreams


    44.TAF Sweet Tooth

    Year 6

    45.Coco Berry

    All mommy charms

    47.TAF Munchy

    48.BNG Twisty tail

    49.Princess Sunbeam

    50.Princess Misty

    51.Princess Taffeta

    52.Princess moondust

    53.Princess Dawn

    54.Newborn twins speckles,



    57.HT Squeezer




    61.Tall Tales

    62.Baby Graffiti

    63.MM Cloud Dreamer


    65.Watercolour sea ponies Foamy and float

    66.Misty and float

    67.Sealight and float

    68.Wave Dancers and float

    69.Seawinkle and float

    70.SW Lady Flutter

    71.Buzzer no wings

    72.SweetBerry Boysenberry Pie

    73.Raspberry Jam

    74.Cranberry Muffins


    76.Cha Cha

    77.Cat nip

    Year 7

    78.MGR Tassles

    79.Diamond Dreams

    80.CC Caramel Crunch


    82.Lemon Treats

    83.Sunshine Mainsail

    84.Beach Ball

    85.Sea Flower

    86.TAF Megan

    87.Fancy pants Baby Bows

    88.Baby Glider

    89.Baby Starburst

    90.Dance and prance Twirler



    93.Tap Dancer


    95.Mom Bright Bouquet

    96.Baby Bright Bouquet

    97.Daddy Sweet Celebrations

    98.WW Whirly

    99.Cool Breeze

    100. Flurry

    101. Moon Jumper

    102. Starry Wings

    103. Playtime brothers Leaper

    104. Racer

    105. Sparkle pony Twinkler

    106. Baby Stripes

    107. Baby Nectar

    108. Baby Lucky Leaf

    109. Baby Leafy

    110. Baby Pockets

    111. Baby Hoppy

    112. SHS Flowerburst

    113. Frilly Flower

    Year 8

    114. Drink and wet Snookums

    115. Cuddles

    116. SHS Sweet Sundrop

    117. Cha cha

    118. Daisy Dancer

    119. Twinkler

    Year 9

    120. Flower Dream

    121. Garden glow

    122. Precious pocket Sweet pocket

    123. Bunny Hop

    124. Pretty beat

    125. Half Note

    126. Baby Brightbow

    127. Baby Sunribbon

    128. Baby Toe Dancer

    129. Secret Surprise Secret Star

    130. Secret Beauty

    131. Pretty Puff

    132. Teeny Tiny Little tabby

    133. Little Whiskers

    134. Pink Princess pony

    Year 10

    135. Colourswirl Lovebeam

    136. Springy

    137. Starswirl

    138. Paradise baby Beach ball

    139. Pineapple

    140. Sundazzle Sunbeam

    141. Sunsplasher

    142. Sunglory

    143. Teeny Tiny Rattles

    144. Tattles

    145. Bootsie

    146. Tootsie

    147. Sniffles

    148. Snookums

    149. Purple sweet talkin

    150. Lovin’ kisses

    151. Flower Fantasy sweet blossom

    152. Flowerbelle

    153. Fancy mermaid pearly

    154. Sea princess

    155. Sea Shimmer

    Any G1 accessories or clothing, combs.

    International Ponies needed

    Activity Club Baby Ponies

    Baby Ponies (First Edition)

    Any UK baby pony

    Tutti Frutti



    Any Dragon that came with Princess ponies



    Ice Crystal




    Non so soft Wind Whistler, Gusty, Shady, Magic Star

    Sea Ponies

    Surf Dancer with Shell

    Wave Breaker with Shell

    Sea Spray with Shell

    Playschool Baby Ponies

    Schooltime Ponies

    Starlight Baby Ponies (except Baby Mischief)

    Cookery Ponies

    Good Weather

    Romance Ponies Love Letter

    35th Anniversary Firefly (MIB preferably)

    - 35th Anniversary Moondancer (MIB preferably)

    - 35th Anniversary Glory (MIB preferably)

    - 35th Anniversary Twilight (MIB preferably)
    Skybreeze likes this.
  9. MLPMommy4Life

    MLPMommy4Life Fraser, your wolf just ate my jelly doughnut!

    Feb 5, 2012
    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:
    Sunny South Florida, West Palm Beach

    Acceptable flaws:
    Hair trims
    Marks on the bottoms of hooves
    Fading (slight)
    I'm not really too picky... as long as she displays nicely, I'm good.

    Unacceptable flaws:
    Marks on the body
    Missing body parts
    Hard body (Plasticizer loss)

    G1 and G3 are okay not to be MIB. G4 MIB is preferred, but not mandatory.

    If I see G1 merchandise in the store, it comes home with ;-)

    ***I'm still looking for the new scented retro Windy... I can't find her anyplace.***

    Extra Information:

    I love to work on the computer, take photos, draw and write stories
    I have 3 cats and a small dog (chihuahua) - They all love cat treats, even the dog LOL
    My favorite colors are orange and blue
    Favorite animals: Cats, dogs, horses, owls and cardinals
    I love reusable items - containers, especially
    I love trinkets, and collect Ladybugs/Lovebugs and Maneki Neko (Lucky) Cats
    I *LOVE* Mountain Dew and crunchy regular cheetos

    Other fandom loves:
    Doctor Who
    Guardians of the Galaxy and Jurassic World (more specifically Chris Pratt)
    Mickey Mouse
    Fast and Furious (Especially Brian O'Conner/Paul Walker)

    Scents I like:

    Pearson's Salted Nut Rolls
    Chocolate / peanut butter cups
    Chocolate covered cherries
    Candy canes, especially the soft kind
    Corn Chips
    Hot Chocolate, especially peppermint flavored!
    I got into Kinder Joys this year... the tiny toys go on my computer at my new job, and I love the frosting and wafers on the other side of the egg.

    Holiday Likes:
    I love all things Halloween except zombies.
    My favorite is black cats.

    Not big on perfume
    Vanilla scent
    Sticky candy (Like taffy...I try to stay away from it because of my dental work)
    Tea of any kind


    Thanks to doing some pony-related work for MustBeJewel, I'm starting a Derpy army. Anything you can find to add outside of the Wal-Mart stuffed toy, the small brushable and the Stuff Happens sticker is very welcomed by me!!!!
    Anything you can find with Discord is also welcomed by me... I just LOVE him.
    Paradise is my favorite G1 pony

    I think that's it... :)
    Skybreeze likes this.

Share This Page